You don’t have control of your keys exactly, but Google can’t see your keys either and you can survive device theft/failure and transfer to a new device. So it’s pretty good in my opinion.
You don’t have control of your keys exactly, but Google can’t see your keys either and you can survive device theft/failure and transfer to a new device. So it’s pretty good in my opinion.
With solution proposed by Google, the keys are stored on the phone. If an attacker gains access to the phone using one of numerous vulnerabilities in Linux kernel, they can bypass any biometric locks. And PINs are short, so they can be easily bruteforced.
The better solution is a physical hardware key that doesn't have tens of megabytes of ponentially vulnerable code and is not controlled by Google.
Same way people can argue endlessly about whether copyrighted software given away for $0 is “free” by defining “free” differently, there can be endless debate about “my keys” among those who define the term differently.
To me, “my keys” are the materials I need to access something. If I rent an apartment, they are still my keys even though I eventually need to return them. Your framing is about ultimate control over the materials rather than their use, so presumably you’d say those apartment keys are not really yours. Both can be right but it becomes a semantic disagreement rather than a substantive one.
Also if you get banned from Google then you might lose access to your keys.
> In some cases, for example, when the older device was lost or damaged, users may need to recover the end-to-end encryption keys from a secure online backup.
> To recover the end-to-end encryption key, the user must provide the lock screen PIN, password, or pattern of another existing device that had access to those keys.
This clearly states that you don't need original device to decrypt the keys: you only need a backup and a PIN code or unlock pattern which are easy to bruteforce.
[1] https://security.googleblog.com/2022/10/SecurityofPasskeysin...
Doesn’t that mean you have to be able to log in to a device that has the keys stored locally? I did not take that to mean you can just give google the pin and they can provide the keys.