That’s what I do. I keep my backup in a fireproof, airtight container
You will have to retrieve your key when you sign to a new service. at this point you risk losing both.
or are you saying you cloned the private keys and know how to correctly advance the counters when you need the backup?
Since I use my Yubikey for SSH, I’m frequently adding both Yubikeys as authorized keys on machines. But I keep an authorized_keys file with both public keys so I don’t need to physically grab my backup