> Is it not enough that a person feels very strongly that one way is more comfortable for them?
Well, no.
If people think something is helping their eyesight, but it's really making it worse, that's a problem.
A lot of dev and gamer oriented sites/apps have a dark mode because it's trendy.
Whether it is objectively better is something I'm very interested in, especially as there are some things (e.g. Twitch's theatre mode) that only offer a dark mode.