I absolutely want RISC-V to succeed but there is a difference between wanting it to succeed and wanting it to become 'dominant' or a 'lingua franca'. I find it a bit unnerving that to 'dominate' other ISAs is something that is being discussed.
I absolutely want RISC-V to succeed but there is a difference between wanting it to succeed and wanting it to become 'dominant' or a 'lingua franca'. I find it a bit unnerving that to 'dominate' other ISAs is something that is being discussed.
The principle of open source yes, but not a particular implementation.
Also an ISA is quite different to a networking protocol where inter-operability is key.
The developers generally don't feed into the "flame wars" but it is a long tradition in the open source world to pick a piece of software and viciously attack the merits and users of competing software. This also happens with users of proprietary software, as with Apple cultists and so on. It is just human nature.
> I’m sure he’d be happy with any set of open archs dominating.
But he wasn’t. He was advocating for his own single arch dominating which is quite different.
Clearly having an open ISA is great news and one that we should support and hope it succeeds.
Advocating for that single ISA to crowd out all other ISAs and render them unviable isn't in my view for a number of reasons.