Can we get away from the “leaky bucket” security paradigm where despite all of the best efforts and gradual improvements, prevalent operating systems “keep on giving” in terms of exploits that are discovered all the time. Is there something akin to what Rust is for programming languages?
Or what about an operating system for AIs? Is the current stack of Linux, GPU drivers, and some ML SDK on top an adequate answer for emerging AI applications?
Or if you still believe in Blockchain applications, what about a native OS for that?
And the list goes on.
All I see in Haiku/BeOS is a pretty, albeit dated user interface. Someone educate me what else they bring to the table.
I would be keen to see more of this list, as two of the three items you mentioned are not at all interesting or useful to me (and, I would presume, to a majority of other users).
Even the other item (#1) is somewhat academic, as modern security practices are generally "good enough" for most people in most use cases. (That is, there is certainly room for improvement, but where we are now isn't nearly as bad as it could be.)
Check out the Genode OS framework
Haiku is an OS for endusers.
Praising the positives of your work at the expense of the criticism of other's work won't do you any favours.
That seems to be a legitimate question, not a dart nor a criticism by any means.
But sometimes my criticisms of Linux are because, well, they are a real and genuine motivation for why I gave up on desktop Linux and devoted even more time to Haiku. It's not as if my criticisms are anything new, there's pages upon pages where Linux users and developers say similar things. I "throw such darts" here to make it clear how Haiku stands in contrast.
- the “Open Source Desktop” is pretty much a Linux monoculture and they are an alternative to that
- the Haiku philosophy is to offer a unified and consistent user experience vs a collection of a thousand independent projects approach ( the Linux experience )
- Haiku offers everything needed for a desktop experience under the banner of a single project ( another way of saying the previous point )
The X11 and Wayland compatibility layers are very different than XQuartz macOS or the Wayland-based WSL GUI are, they are much more tightly integrated into Haiku. While you are still going to notice some seams here and there, overall the experience is much more like a "full port" than most other OSes have on this point.
More to the point, all ported applications are still running on top of Haiku's kernel, Haiku's window manager / display server, Haiku's media services, Haiku's init system, Haiku's package manager, etc. On Linux, all those things come from separate projects, and some of them can even be swapped out within a Linux distribution, never mind between distributions. Not so on Haiku.
I hear what you're saying and I do understand the point you're trying to make. However, I think it's interesting to point out just how app-centric systems have become, with many apps even shipping essentially their own unique HIG and look and feel.
If you look at Haiku's competitors, 10 years ago they were all much more editorialized with a strong sense of what a proper, native app for them should look like. And despite all having more such native apps than Haiku has now, the trends have - at least for the time being - pulled away from that. If Haiku gets more popular it'll similarly become subject to simply running the most popular software.
Haiku has its own set of tools.
As long as it's integrated it might avoid Lisp Curse of Linux. It's too easy to fork and too hard to reintegrate.