The problem with MAiD the way Canada implemented it is that there are incentives for the system to off you. In that scenario you mention with the doctor he didn't get paid to show you the switch, and he risks being charged if his healthy patients start dying. Now it's risk free, he could clear his schedule for the holidays and face no recriminations.
> is it right for someone to have the freedom to choose the time and manner of their own death
That's not the question that ended up being asked, it's can a doctor recommend that your depressed child be killed before they've put any effort into therapy.
Or, can a hospital administrator reward the nurses' pod with the most patient suicides with a bonus?
> is that a compassionate death should be an option [...] no reasonable prospect of turning around a terrible situation [...] no reasonable prospect of recovery
Yeah, that's not how it works. They're supposed to ask that sort of stuff, and you aren't supposed to want to die for lack of some food, but in fact it's not helping the people you think and not saving those you'd wish.