In fact, that would make them more of a beast (as sometimes such people are reffered as), not less. Beast are what they are, they're not what they "chose" to be either...
I sure don't agree with unlawful punishment or cruel torment as punishment of course, whatever the crime - as some people think somebody being like that gives them a free ride to kill/torture them. I think those people are also sick, and just finding a convenient widely agreed target for their violent urges...
Sure, because they simply would not be serial killers, if they have never killed.
So yes, it is important to make the clear distinction between people who have done horrible things and those, who have fantasies about it and not mix them all together.
Part of what makes us human is impulse control.
I might feel the urge to beat someone - but only if I would let that part of myself go, then there is a real problem as then something happened.
With pedophiles it is of course a bit more tricky. Would you let someone close to your kids, if you knew they have fantasies about sex with them, but so far he has showed restraint?
"But stigmatizing thoughts to the point where you can't ask for help with the thoughts seems like a recipe for problems."
Yes, there was the famous incident, where one pilot decided to suicide himself and the whole plane with him. Smart populistic politicians reacted by saying they need a new law that says psychotherapists who treat pilots, must inform the authorities when the pilot has dark thoughts. Awesome way to hinder people from getting therapy as they could never open up if they know it might lead to their job being taken away.
Therapies must be and remain confidential to have a chance of working.
I don't get the utility of making ontological statements about people including serial killers. Maybe someone who does find utility in them could chime in and explain it.
No, but nobody said it would be "just as". It would still be creepy as hell though, if one did it all the time.
And you never know until they're dead themselves if they'll pass into action either. Sure, this is the case with people not fantasizing about murders too -- they can still commit murder. But fantasizing makes it sound quite more likely. It's also one of the creepiest ways for someone to think of you (as their fantasy murder victim)...
"Any better" was used in the context of the question whether being an X person who does X because genetics is better than being an X person who does X by choice. To which I replied that it's not "any better" (both result in many people being murdered horrifically).
"Just as" was used in the context of the question whether fantasizing about X is "just as" bad as doing X. To which I replied that it's not "just as bad", but it's still a bad/creepy thing.
So not the same "semantic content" at all given the context.
Instead, uppon rereading, I think your point was that "they can't help it, they were born that way" isn't an excuse. I agree there, though the footnote should be that people who "can't help but feel that way" shouldn't be so demonized for just their thoughts that they can't ask for help.
That entire special[1] is side-splittingly funny. One of my favorite comedians. Comedy!
Now, a normal person sure can e.g. in anger have a momentary revenge fantasy of killing somebody thats being a jerk, but that's not the same I'd say as a constant urge for something like that. Then it's part of personality.
If someone is unlucky enough to be born attracted to children and they control themselves such that they don't act on those urges then I'd consider that quite admirable.
If someone can't control something, then the "admirable" quality of controlling it would be impossible. If they do control it (admirably) then it's by definition under the person's control. If what you mean is that the desire is not under their control but refraining from acting upon it is, then is it admirable for someone to repress their homosexuality in, say, Iran? Or is that just a matter of survival? In that case, don't we say it's admirable for someone to have the courage to be themselves in the face of enormous risk, and that repressing individual sexuality is a violation of human rights?
The difference, of course, being that homosexuality doesn't imply non-consensual acts; no one is hurt by it. It could be that some pedophiles refrain from molesting children because some internal moral standard tells them it would hurt the child, but it seems more likely that they only refrain when and where they could get into trouble for it. Just looking at what an outlier "teens under 18" is on that chart... it's as popularly a fetish as "lips" or "thighs" (Y-axis), but it sits way out in the taboo area near bestiality. That's gotta be because it's illegal. Almost everything right of 70% is illegal, and its position correlates roughly to "how illegal is it".
By that logic, the majority of heterosexual men only refrain from rape because they could get in trouble for it?
>> some pedophiles refrain from [...]
So no, not the majority of men, just the majority of rapists (or potential rapists) would rape if they could. According to the survey, interest in "violating another's consent" sits at around 17%.
The majority of men don't have to "refrain" from pedophilia, because the majority aren't sexually interested in children. Similarly, the majority of men aren't interested in raping people.
I'm confused. You're saying they are interested in sex, but not in rape, with their object of attraction. Okay. So does the same apply to pedophiles? Is the majority of pedophiles also not interested in raping anyone?
But I mean, the mundane fact of wanting to have sex with someone you can't have sex with (for any number of reasons) doesn't mean you're going to rape them. Or woild ever want to rape them. Why? Because you want to have sex with them under the condition that they want to have sex with you. Consensual sex is the kind of sex you crave and want to have. Sex is, obviously, different and better if both parties consent to it, to you, because you're not a rapist.
So my contention is that potential rapists are the subset of men who aren't concerned with consent (not those who just desire someone they can't have). And pedophiles are a subset of that.
In other words, you're assuming that attraction means someone would rape; I'm saying that an abnormal and antisocial impulse to violate someone's rights is a prerequisite for most rape, not simply attraction.
To map it out:
heterosexual men:
(a) interested (or acting) on consentual sex with adult women: fine
(b) interested (or acting) non-consentual sex with adult women: bad
pedos:
(a) interested (or acting) non-consentual sex with children: bad
It's not symmetrical, as there's no (b) option in the second case. Pedophilia is always about non-consentual sex (that is rape), whether acted upon or not.
(In heterosexual men rape is mostly about power. In pedos, it can be about both power and desire, but that desire is still by definition a rape desire, as it can't ever be consentual).
A sizable chunk of heterosexual men (and possibly women), on the other hand, would indeed have sex with available women at every opportunity, if they could not get in trouble for it - you know, like the stigma of adultery, divorces, and stuff.
Yes, this is what I mean.
> The difference, of course, being that homosexuality doesn't imply non-consensual acts; no one is hurt by it.
Indeed. There is no moral imperative to refrain from that which doesn't cause harm.
> It could be that some pedophiles refrain from molesting children because some internal moral standard tells them it would hurt the child, but it seems more likely that they only refrain when and where they could get into trouble for it.
To me it seems likely that the majority of pedophiles (who have the thoughts) make at least some effort to refrain from molesting children, because I believe that most people care about others and want to do right by them as best they can. In many ways this is no different to anyone refraining from forcing themselves upon someone they are attracted to but who isn't interested in them, which is of course a commonplace and unremarkable occurrence. The difference of course being that if someone is exclusively attracted to children then they may find it difficult to find an outlet for their desire, which could make this more difficult for them.
How often do you watch and enjoy media where people are being constantly murdered? Are we terrible people because we enjoy John Wick?
And what's with this "constant urge" bullshit? Do most people want to constantly fuck every second of every day?
You're doing a lot of post-rationalizing something you've already decided.
Does enjoying John Wick means fantasicizing of you killing actual people in any kind of a realistic setting? Or just enjoying the plot and action on the screen?
Do people enjoying John Wick have an urge to do killing themselves but just control it? Or are just watching a movie, the same way they'd watch a sci-fi film or superheroes in spandex, and not think much about it afterwards?
>And what's with this "constant urge" bullshit? Do most people want to constantly fuck every second of every day?
Why, does it have to be "every second of every day" to be considered constant?
Because once a day/week/month or at every time you see a child is not enough to qualify as such?
But if we're being pedantic about "constant" (whose dictionary definition and use includes usages not "every second of every day", such as "he's in constant trouble with the police"), they do say that people think about sex a lot: twice an hour for college age men it says here: https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-sexual-continuum...
Depends on your age and gender, I suppose. For most 15 year-old boys, the answer is yes, they do want to constantly fuck every second of the day.
Far more than we'll ever know. I am convinced most of them get away with it, and far more manage to keep it in the realm of fantasy. I'm not sure I really want to know the real number.