I have had good experiences at bars and restaurants where I input my orders online whenever I want, perhaps multiple times throughout the meal, and the waitstaff bring them out promptly. I obviously don't have data, but it feels twice as fast since I never have to wave people down just to relay my orders.
This isn't for everyone, and it's not for every situation. But for the right circumstances applications, this is really quite convenient and pleasant.
The first had QR codes at the table, where you _must_ order using your phone. You cannot have multiple phones ordering at the same table at the same time. It hard-limited you to making orders only once every 10 minutes. This can be particularly problematic when the same limit applies to all tables, regardless of the number of people at the table. Orders would variably be delivered by a person or one of those BellaBot serving robots [1]. I had no problem pulling my plates off the tray and pressing the button to dismiss it, but other tables clearly struggled with it. At some larger tables, the robot would stop near the far end of the table and a person would have to get out of their chair to fetch their own food. Sometimes a server would see it happen and assist the table, but it was sad to see older people struggling with it.
The second place I went to had paper menus which you just checked off what you wanted. There was no limit on how much you could order at once, and they didn't arbitrarily throttle you.
Both restaurants had a similar number of tables with 3-4 staff in the dining room at any given time. The first restaurant was actually a miserable customer experience, with the only take-away being how interesting it was that the novelty made the experience so much worse. I will unlikely go back to that first restaurant, while the second one will always be on the rotating list that me and my wife go to.
I _really_ dislike having to read a menu on my phone or struggle with some low-quality ordering software. From what I could tell, the first restaurant saved nothing on staffing from their "automation."
Regarding the staffing, I think the robot server is designed to help save on staffing (not the throttling policy, which may also be intended to not overwhelm the kitchen).
My (good) experiences have been at bars and outdoor restaurants, where normal process of placing additional orders is usually slow in my experience, giving the new approach a chance to shine.
I agree with you re: the novelty aspect and personally I dislike ordering on my phone, but will tolerate it for the places where it makes the overall experience better.
My beer was brought swiftly by waitstaff. My meal was delivered on an automated cart. I had to get up to get my order, but I was to impressed by the automated cart to be annoyed at any inconvenience.
I also started phoning in orders instead of using most other services too (Uber Eats, Grubhub, Yelp) because it’s just quicker
Not sure why you find it ridiculous. The part you quote, taken on its own, seems valid, reasonable, sensible.
You ridicule it, but I don't see why.
I recommend this paper to everyone: https://ckrybus.com/static/papers/Bainbridge_1983_Automatica...
> What a ridiculous article. Why is this on HN
This on the other hand is sentence completely devoid of potatoes, let alone meat. Would you care to expand on why you find it ridiculous?