So "Should we abolish prisons?" boils down to "are the very real harms of prisons still less than the theoretical harms prevented by prisons?" I'm not confident about either side of that argument but it's worth considering.
It has started to feel like they're for anything that makes prisons unworkable, even if it kills prisoners in the meantime and leaves others on the street, than reforming the system because they wouldn't be able to argue against a humane and proportional prison.
Prisons suck but they suck less than it did without them. Without alternative ways to handle the preexisting problems prison abolition is a step backwards.
If you build prisons, they will be filled. When you have lots of hammers, everything is nails.
If we did build low-level prisons we'd not only have a solution for the interim, but it'd be an improvement over current conditions. I think they'd not only handle the new crime, but could pull non-violent offenders from the existing prisons as well - reducing overcrowding and better handling the actual danger the prisoners pose.
> Incarceration is an expensive way to not really solve the problem of crime.
Sure, and fire trucks don't solve fire. But both are part of the solution.
> addressing people's basic needs
What about crime that's not caused by poverty or need, like rape? There'll always be a need to lock people up.
I share the goal of lowering that number but I can't see how it gets to zero.
> and had better mental and healthcare we'd see less crime
Prisons aren't alone in not working as intended - that award goes to most one-size-fits-all government programs.
Those interventions aren't actually likely to solve the problem. They'll misdiagnose the problem, pick a horrible solution, and fail to execute properly anyways. I've seen this first hand with drug policy and addiction treatment. Our over-funded system is the most dangerous place to be. An addict on the streets of some poor city in the middle of nowhere has better outcomes.
Certainly we still have problems with violence and other kinds of harm done by people to people.
If you think building more prisons will solve these problems (which are probably various and not uniform or monolithic), when we already incarcerate more people than literally anywhere else on the planet, I think the burden of proof is on you to show that building more prisons will somehow help. It doesn't seem obvious to me. As you say, building more prisons does not seem to me to be an intervention likely to help, as demonstrated by our experience so far.
In addition, there'd now be a reasonable punishment for small crimes and we could start punishing people who now fall through the cracks before they become a problem.
> I think the burden of proof is on you to show that building more prisons will somehow help.
You're not using them correctly. Stop breaking the system by putting mental patients and minor criminals in prisons. Stop overcrowding, underfunding, letting sadists be guards, etc, etc, and then see if they work.
Besides, I'm not saying more, I'm saying new and appropriate ones. You can repurpose the old ones once prisoners are transferred.
This is why people are more against minimum-security prisons than maximum; minimum security prisons are an easy and obvious win and it hurts the "all prisons bad" narrative by showing the options aren't just gulags or nothing.
https://www.nbcnews.com/think/opinion/thinking-about-how-abo...