I'm honestly confused when I hear people say they still use X forwarding and it has no slowdown. It's known to be one of the worst possible options for remoting, the core protocol doesn't even support image/video compression. RDP runs circles around it.
This is exactly my confusion, why people say there is one. I guess things would be different if I was trying to do it over low bandwidth high latency sat connection or something. At least with connections as slow as 50mbps I have not noticed any issue, I don’t have anything slower to readily test to see what people are talking about. I’ve no doubt it’s theoretically slower due to e.g. compression but that doesn’t seem to be a big practical concern at least for most connections and use cases.
I’ve found it highly concerning because the other solutions will not work for me, but adherents seem to insist what’s working for me doesn’t.
Edit: I want to say that nearly everything in X11 is like this. It seems to work ok at first glance but it breaks horribly when you get outside the design parameters of a mainframe in 1987. So basically, transferring software-rendered images over a high-bandwidth LAN connection and that's it.
I understand that not everyone has > 50 mbps connections but I don’t think this is a contrived fringe edge case either. Meanwhile, the present alternative of “just use rdp” or “just install this package” is completely infeasible for me. And I mean, ant some point, bandwidth is a factor no matter what you do, though I agree more efficient is theoretically better. Unfortunately my job is going to get a lot harder down the road when X is retired for good.
I doubt that X11 is going to disappear for good. It will still always be around for running the odd old X client or for historical curiosity. Just like how you can still emulate the original Macintosh (released the same year as the original version of X!).
So I guess you can say it’s someone else’s problem but it sure feels like my problem.