[flagged]
Edit: I suppose I should clarify one more bit. For HN we would decide this based not on the title, but rather on the article—whether or not it can support an intellectually curious conversation without devolving into flamewar, as the site mandate calls for (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html). My take on the OP was "yes it can", although we're starting to see religious flamelets eating into the margins even in this thread.