My opinion is that if something is publicly available on the internet, then an AI should be allowed to train on it
My opinion is that if something is publicly available on the internet, then an AI should be allowed to train on it
The AI doesn't grok the code, it just copies it. This is fine for art, because accuracy isn't required. It's not fine for code, because code needs to be accurate.
Generating code using an AI is going to lead to vulnerabilities which were either present in the original training code, or have been created by mis-applying training code.
Granted, junior devs (hell, even senior devs) can and will make the same mistakes, but at least someone understands the code and can fix the vulnerability relatively easily once it has been exposed. The AI doesn't understand that it made a mistake, and has no idea how to fix it.
Coding is far more utilitarian - so if an AI is taking others' original ideas and effectively passing them off as it's own, companies become less likely to feel they need to employ the originator.
Are you sure it was the same individual? Because otherwise all you've observed is two people with two different opinions.