I would love to see an integration where the discussion on a Medium post is viewable both as comments at the bottom of the page and as Fediverse posts. (This is what I was pushing in https://www.jefftk.com/p/mastodon-replies-as-comments)
I would love to see an integration where the discussion on a Medium post is viewable both as comments at the bottom of the page and as Fediverse posts. (This is what I was pushing in https://www.jefftk.com/p/mastodon-replies-as-comments)
Definitely a possibility. Where we ended up landing is that Mastodon is culturally short form. From prior experience just syndicating into a short form ecosystem is kind of lame even if the ActivityPub protocol supports it. So if we have Medium authors on this part of the fediverse then we want to encourage them to be fully there.
The medium-length fediverse, i.e. blogs and articles, is still emerging and for us is also a much more complicated product question. But definitely open to it.
This is essentially how blogs are promoted on Twitter and Mastodon already (though people often create longer threads) so it's a "paving the cowpaths" strategy.
Since you can do it already, the only difference would be having an official short post representing the article, which would be a focal point for discussion about the article.
For better or worse. Maybe having a focal point for article discussion is bad?
This is still somewhat significant because if you see comments from @someone@me.dm you'll know it's the person who goes by the same name as a Medium author, who you might know from elsewhere. This would be more effective if the Mastodon instance were at something like fed.medium.com though.
Mastodon represents a short form corner of the fediverse. To participate in this corner via a medium-length tool would mean participation from people who are blindly syndicating at worst, and having a disconnected experience at best. It'd be disrespectful to the community there.
Instead, Medium authors should be fully present as short form participants, even if all they want to do is share a link.
To speak in the town square you need to be present in the town square. In the case of Mastodon, that means reading and writing from a short-form app.
The point of adding ActivityPub (both ways) would be to be part of a much, much smaller blog-length corner of the fediverse. It's interesting, but is fundamentally a different goal.