You're mistaking redistribution for destruction...
Sure, things are technically more equal if everyone becomes homeless. But there wasn't really a redistribution...
You're mistaking redistribution for destruction...
Sure, things are technically more equal if everyone becomes homeless. But there wasn't really a redistribution...
No, you are. With respect, you should consider reading some history. Try reading about the conditions of the peasantry after the black plague, or postwar Europe, or even the various falls of the various iterations of Rome. Fire destroys the previous order, yes, but it also sows the seeds for growth.
But fire bad! Yes, yes, I know; but this forest isn't the only forest, nor is it the only possible forest. Fire bad, but fire is the only way to fix this situation, because of the way "we" have "managed" our "forests" for as long as I've been alive. Maybe I need to be a Boomer to properly "understand". If there's another solution, I'm all ears, but history suggests that fire is the only solution.
You're ignoring base effects.
Of course peasants are going to "prosper" (on paper) if agriculture goes from 1% of the economy to 100%.
And, again, this isn't a "wealth redistribution". You've taken out 99% of the economy and left the remaining 1% in tact. It didn't grow. But it did grow relative to the rest that was destroyed.
How long until the growth occurs, and how fast will it take to get back to the current state of things?
Add to that how a lot of people have seen their societies become substantially worse of as a whole - yes, iPhones are awesome and modern cars are safer and so on, but instead of having a union job you pee in bottles in Amazon warehouse, and instead of buying a home you are forever renting a studio apartment.
The Simpsons titular family of one high school educated guy with house and three kids on single income went from "typical boring dude" to "impossible dream" over the course of one or two generations, after all.