I agree that Windows and mac is a bit more polished, but they both also come with crapware and spyware so I can take the crashes..
[1]: https://www.scottrlarson.com/publications/publication-transi...
Can you detail a bit more?, what's the hardware, what happened (what was corrupted?), where were you running Linux from?, and how long ago?
Only times I've actually encountered issues recently were with old microSD cards on raspberry pi and nvidia drivers causing a mess on update sometimes.
Might happen if you upgrade windows too.
The other issue with grub error, kind of weird, maybe adding hard drives might cause problems, or some issue during upgrade.
Windows is user hostile and God awful slow in comparison.
Every time linux desktop comes up, there are tons of people having issues. Meanwhile, I can point to material improvements Microsoft has made to the windows core that mitigate many of these complaints - improvements that landed in both 10 and 11, and that simply don't exist on the Linux desktop.
Simply put, the Linux desktop is hardly anywhere close to prime time. Efforts from Valve and Canonical have gone a long way in the last few years to catch up, but it's hardly a "done deal".
Yeah I am going to have to disagree with you there. Been running PopOS for a year and its pretty close to were it needs to be.
Absolutely not anywhere close where it needs to be.
I hear YOU in YOUR belief that desktop linux is stable and ready for primetime. Maybe some day that'll be true. I think it'll probably be sooner than I think, but it's not there yet.
Desktop linux still has tons of rough edges, weird glitches, and is still quite buggy the second you take it out of the rather narrowly defined "best hardware" list. It's come a long way, but even the teams building these distros have their own "100 papercuts" lists, and the stuff on there is pretty low hanging fruit, even today.
- HDR support. Full stop.
- Multi monitor / multi resolution support (yes, they support it on paper but in reality it's lacking)
- Multi vendor GPU support - my igr is amd, my external is nvidia
- Hibernate mode (very rough support on linux, still even today!)
- I have never gotten video to play without tearing, over 15 solid years of using linux on the desktop as a side box on bare metal. Please someone tell me what I'm doing wrong.
- Thunderbolt networking
- I recently installed ubuntu lts and then ran updates, and then the machine refused to boot. That was very cool!
and as far as niceties go, Win11 adds excellent tiling support, a better control panel, better network drive integration, and a more clear filesystem exposure for devices - network or otherwise.
I have a very long list of additional deficiencies.
And yes, I am very disappointed with Win11. I'm still on 10 for my main machine. I keep giving desktop linux a shot and running into massive, deal-breaking issues. Frankly, I'm sick of microsoft's incompetence but their technical foundation is still, even now, strong than desktop linux's.
I would like nothing more than to ditch microsoft, but every time I try, it's nothing but dead ends. I use ubuntu via VM frequently, including hosting my dev env - I wish it was the host.
FWIW my second machine is a ubuntu lts desktop machine, I have only had a few dist upgrades work flawlessly in my 15 years of running it. I gave up a long time ago and blow it away when LTS support ends.
For image based installs, it is possible to customize distro installers. Cubic is a tool to do so for Ubuntu/Debian based distros for example. And with NixOS or Guix you can do some pretty crazy stuff which don't have any compliment in the Windows world.
As unfair as it seems, they are desktop linux issues, not Nvidia issues. If your OS does not work with the most popular discrete graphics solution, it's a "you" problem. Like I said, completely unfair :)
Speaking of which, the windows graphics subsystem is light years ahead of anything on the linux desktop. It can handle a driver AND card kernel crash, restart the card, and your system keeps running. It's actually very impressive.
> Cubic
That is installing with a disk image, which is a different thing than an image based install (Windows DISM).
> NixOS or Guix
This is much closer to the reproducible install mechanism windows has, although still has some key deficiencies (and key benefits that windows doesn't have!). I think this is the future, but IME is not completely ready for casual desktop use.
If I owe the bank $1000, it's my problem. If I owe the bank $1,000,000,000, then it's their problem.
Apple is a terrible example to use. Apple does not play that game, it's very clear going in that you're buying more of an appliance. Also, that $6000+ desktop is literally the last of their lineup on Intel and is clearly on its way out - it will probably be replaced by something without PCIe. Not saying if that's good or bad, just that it's Apple. Personally, I think it's quite bad, though...
That would be a great benefit, agreed. But not a current utter show stopper.
> I have never gotten video to play without tearing, over 15 solid years of using linux on the desktop as a side box on bare metal. Please someone tell me what I'm doing wrong.
Selection of a properly supported GPU and their capable drivers? I play various video formats be it browser based (Youtube, Netflix, Jellyfin, etc) or VLC/file based without any video tearing. Although, I don't ever try to play fullscreen so maybe that has something to do with it.
I think you underestimate how fast a Windows install gets slow and bloated.
On the GNU/Linux side I have this experience when I need to use Nvidia stuff.
Nvidia open source community modules sucks because they're on-purpose limited by Nvidia firmware.
Nvidia proprietary modules take forever to compile and install, and will break your system every time updates are force-interrupted by any reason.
I love my Linux, but I just can't agree with this argument against modern Windows. The Windows installation on my desktop at work dates back to the original release of Windows 10, back in 2015 or so. It's had the guts upgraded twice (motherboard, CPU, ram). It still runs great.
In my many years of experience, I have found desktop linux to be even worse. Frankly, I'm annoyed this is a problem on any OS. App containers are the way forward, and snapd is terrible (firefox updates, for example, are awful)