Government answers to it's people.
Equifax answers to it's shareholders.
IRS already has that info. The people have the power to control and influence how that data is handled, and distributed. We have no power to compel Equifax to do anything.
I think you understand that the point of taking this course of action is to prevent/reduce these kinds of abuses from happening.
The goal isn't to enshrine abuse of authority in governmental agencies, but to prevent nongovernmental agencies from abusing that authority.
I would much rather just whack the big players with antitrust law than give their power to some government agency. A worthless mission statement of some bureaucracy is just that, worthless. If said bureaucracy is using the same information Equifax is using to provide the same services the abuse potential is right there and it's probably only a matter of time until it starts getting used to screw whoever the outgroup of the minute is.
What is sorely needed is privacy legislation that says that data about an individual is fundamentally the property of that individual, and that the license for commercially storing/processing an individual's data can be revoked at any time. Having choices is the requisite first step to having competition.
What will having a market of providers for this service do for me that having a crown corporation or federal ministry won't?
Let's look at it the other way. Could you imagine privatizing the IRS. Why would I want that?
Your information is not broadcasted to all companies in existence only those who you've authorized (or have been authorized on your behalf by a malicious actor / identify thief).
This is not udp.
Famously, Experian ("freecreditreport.com") sold partially filled form information. This is before submission and up to 9 times. Feel free to go to the site signup today and watch the information being streamed (in a hashed form) from your developer console.
Your second paragraph is false, AFAIK. In the USA, credit bureaus are legally allowed to sell lots of your info to debt collectors and financial service companies. (According to DoanLaw.com) this is why you get “prescreening” offers for credit cards, mortgage refis, etc.
- HIPPA is for health care providers and their vendors
- Traditional wired telecom has long been protected. And fraud over telecom has a special wire fraud statute.
- Mail thru the USPS
- COPPA for PII of under 13 data
- Federal election law prevents election records used for commercial purposes
- basically all of the government classified data system