Those were not cases about 'generators' but about 'aggregators', a completely different class of application.
Those were not cases about 'generators' but about 'aggregators', a completely different class of application.
Those cases hinged on republishing works or significant parts of works as themselves, they weren't trying to pass them off as new, original works in their own right.
And this is exactly what this court case is about, whether or not Stable Diffusion ultimately is just another - complex - form of mechanical transformation or whether it creates original work.
In my opinion the only things all of these companies get wrong is that they (1) failed to obtain consent from the suppliers of the inputs to their models and (2) that they themselves have not contributed even a little bit of the input data.
The ultimate laugh test is whether or not these companies themselves slap (C) signs on everything and are willing to litigate when they believe their rights are the ones that are infringed upon. I hope for an outcome where opt-in will become the norm, that would seem to be a reasonable middle ground.
Finally, note that copyright is not a local concept but a global one - and has been for a long time - and that anything that happens on that front will have to ratified in a different forum than some US court.
No, it's not at all. This court case is about:
Plaintiffs Sarah Andersen, Kelly McKernan, and Karla Ortiz (“Plaintiffs”), on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated, bring this Class Action Complaint (the “Complaint”) against Defendants Stability AI Ltd. and Stability AI, Inc. (collectively “Stability”); Midjourney, Inc. (“Midjourney”); and DeviantArt, Inc. (“DeviantArt”) (all collectively “Defendants”) for:
1.) direct and vicarious copyright infringement under 17 U.S.C. § 501;
2.) violation of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, 17 U.S.C. §§ 1201–1205 (the “DMCA”);
3.) violation of Plaintiffs’ statutory and common law rights of publicity, Cal. Civ. Code section 3344;
4.) violation of Unfair Competition law, Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 17200, et seq.;
5.) and declaratory relief.
So for each of those complaints the defense needs to establish that their actions fit a different narrative, one that is legally coherent and against the claims for damages.
So for copyright infringement they are going to go for a fair use defense. I'm sure they won't only reference VCRs and Google Books! I'm certain they won't talk about "aggregators" and "generators" because this is not a Supreme Court opinion. They're going to use the established legal doctrines. I'm sure that their lawyers have plenty of other relevant case law at their disposal.
As for DMCA and rights of publicity, this seems to be what motivated Stability AI to adhere to "takedown requests" as they probably had some lawyer whispering in their ear that they probably don't want to spend the time and money testing this in court if it doesn't really impact the marketability of their tool.
I haven't ready anything about the Unfair Competition law in California.
Judges are far from stupid and a fair use defense requires that you primarily acknowledge that you are in fact infringing but that you feel that because it is fair use you should be allowed to continue to do so. This is a pretty risky strategy, especially when you are a party that is in the business of hosting other people's creative content.
We'll see how it all pans out, personally I think their position would be much, much stronger if they had bothered to obtain consent, even an opt-out email that if not responded to within say 3 months would count as consent (and no: obviously that's not the same but we're comparing the relative size of fig-leaves here).
As it stands I don't see how their 'fair use defense' will hold together under scrutiny without opening a much bigger can of worms.
[1] They had to admit infringement because of their first line of defense, then the fall-back required them to point at the site where they presumably took the code from which they could not. Don't interrupt your opponent when they are making mistakes.
This doctrine gives the lower courts a clear test that doesn't require diving deep into arguments about what it means for "computers to learn ideas" or for "language models to author".
The problem with an opt-in model is that it puts enough of a burden on a language model that it discourages non-infringing commercial creation. The opt-out-on-request model, which would need some form of legislation and probably informed by both the DMCA and right-to-be-forgotten in Euro area, would be preferable as it would have much less of a burden on model creators.
You seem to be making a very convoluted argument that eventually boils down to 'because it is useful it must be right', aka an argument from utility. But copyright law has time and again been proven to be highly resilient against such arguments. You either have rights or you don't and in a moment of clairvoyance the people that came up with the current incarnation decided that it is such an important thing that it gets bestowed upon creation. No registration required (though it can help). Just making something and boom you have a bunch of rights which you can only contract out of.
I don't think any utilitarian argument that results in the creation of new works based on the works of others will make those rights go away.
I've read your other comments and I see that this tool is useful to you but don't be persuaded so easily by the utility: If I stole your work and passed it off as my own it might be very useful to society, especially if I re-licensed it under more permissive terms or even placed in the public domain. But I would be clearly infringing on your rights. You may in fact not be in a position to claim these works as your creation.
The fact that 'my' work has a few hundred or even a few thousand such inputs rather than just one does not change the principle: I did not create the work, and that is the bit that really matters, unless you are creating a work it doesn't matter if you have the equivalent of a bitcoin tumbler for art at your disposal to pretend that you have created a work. You did not. The fact that you used a tool that obfuscates attribution and overrules the licensing terms of the original copyright holders does not mean that you can claim your hands are clean: you know exactly what is going on behind the scenes.
Personally I won't go within a mile of these tools to create work that I put my name under .
So I’ve used Stable Diffusion and I’m “literally” stealing from every artist. Prove it. Get a warrant to search my premises for signs of illegal language model use. How do you get a warrant with an image that has no visual evidence of being a copy?
I can prove to you that my writing and my code are mine because you can stand behind me and look over my shoulder to see that I am creating it, one bit (or at most 8) at the time. Visual evidence of it being a copy is not required: what's required is a track of creation aka provenance. This is a very well defined area in copyright. So the proof would be trivial: you recreate your work again, without access to Stable Diffusion or equivalent, while being monitored and if you can not then that would count as a bust in my book. If you're a good enough artist that you can do that and you merely use SD as a way to get some inspiration then that's another matter. But if the output of SD is in the workflow in such a way that its output is directly your input then that would be troublesome (to me). If it is copied then that still would be troublesome (to me). If you feel ok with that it is entirely up to you, but I have my views on that, which I'm perfectly at liberty to share.
And of course once you've made it work likely it is trivial to make it again so probably the above test conditions would need some sharpening but you get the principle.
Without provenance you are still creating art, but you are not creating original art. And if you were a good enough artist before SD then you should still be after, even if you're not using it and everybody else is, at least your work will be and will continue to be original.
I'm trying to imagine a world in which Rembrandt van Rijn admitted to using SD to create the Nightwatch, projecting it on a big canvas and then erasing the prompt. I figure it wouldn't give me quite the same feeling that it does today. Of course artists will use the tools that are at their disposal, but this tool essentially is a pocket sized library of all the other art that could be vacuumed up into the model and that just doesn't sit right with me. Which parts are yours and which parts are SD? If you claim an outsider can't un-entangle them to the point where cause and effect are separated do you really feel that that is the bar that should be met? If so what if I trained a model on your art exclusively and then used that to produce prompt driven 'art' to compete with you, would you think that's fair? And if not, why would the number of inputs be a factor? It's the principles that matter.
FWIW my dad made a living as a painter for quite a few years and even though I can't paint worth anything I know enough about brush technique to get oil to stick to canvas. Given this tool I could produce 'art' that I probably could pass off as original and it would likely not be detected by your standard.
But without the tool I would be absolutely hopeless so that's a pretty good argument. The more of an artist someone is the more brittle that argument becomes, there may well be a border beyond which what someone creates using such a tool does qualify as original work but again, to me, such a work would feel tainted.
Do you disclose the use of SD to the customers that buy these works?
Also, Stable Diffusion is already on my laptop so I don’t need an Internet connection, but I digress.
You’re right, I can’t make the same art with Stable Diffusion as without. The same holds for the art I can make with DAW software like Logic Pro and without. Or my guitar and without. Basically you’re leaving me with nothing but my voice, and personally, I’m in luck because I do sing and have already put effort into getting better.
I can’t see how an image that has never existed before cannot be considered original… it might not have taken much effort, but that’s something else entirely! How is any part of photography even remotely considered original in your theory of art?
The burden is on the accuser but the accuser has been 'shredded' and that makes them all but anonymous. So if you dilute inputs enough then you can ignore the rights? There is a close equivalent to this in music sampling. The rule there is that if you want to remix someone else's production that you will have to ask for their permission, which, crucially, they are not required to give.
https://www.romanolaw.com/2022/10/14/music-sampling-rights-w...
This seems to me to be a reasonable middle ground. Once you start breaking things down further it gets harder and harder to nail down where the limit lies. In music you probably won't find any useful samples shorter than 1/32th of a beat and even that would be pushing the limits. But the rules don't say anything about how long those samples are: even the tiniest sliver would have to be accounted for: you would need permission. And yes the burden is on the accuser. But it would make sense from an ethical point of view and as an artist to just play by the rules, rather than to see what you can get away with and so even for short samples that might never be detected by that particular accuser as a rule permission is obtained.
> You’re right, I can’t make the same art with Stable Diffusion as without. The same holds for the art I can make with DAW software like Logic Pro and without. Or my guitar and without. Basically you’re leaving me with nothing but my voice, and personally, I’m in luck because I do sing and have already put effort into getting better.
That's disingeneous and you are likely well aware of it, but just to spell it out: Logic Pro 'Sample Packs' all have clear attribution and use rights attached, and your guitar is (unless it is some advanced model that I'm not currently aware of) unable to make you play like Al Di Meola without putting in the endless hours of practice. Neither of these contain a combined mountain of copyrighted artists works that you can then re-use at your discretion without attribution and if and when they do those are very carefully sourced and marked as such. So the comparison with SD doesn't hold.
> I can’t see how an image that has never existed before cannot be considered original…
Ok, so I have this little piece of software here, it allows me to extract the notes, durations and volumes of individual notes of a piano piece and then I can re-play those notes using any instrument from an enormous bank of synthesized sounds. Do you feel that this should count as original work because 'it has never existed before' or do you feel that this is a mechanical transformation and that the original creator should be able to sue me for creating a derived work? Does the mechanism of the derivation count?
> it might not have taken much effort, but that’s something else entirely
Agreed, Marc Rebillet comes to mind (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3vBwRfQbXkg) , but he has 3 decades of experience which allows him to create in a few minutes what would take others weeks (or they might never be able to do anything).
> How is any part of photography even remotely considered original in your theory of art?
Photography is original art when it goes beyond 'just reproduction'. My brother, who is a pretty good photographer has two 'modes' in the first one he is simply registering an event, a wedding or something else that needs to be documented. He most likely would not consider this to be even close to his best work and certainly not in the level of artistry involved. In his other mode he can spend a crazy amount of time arranging the shot, including getting up at odd hours of the night, creating special vantage points, the right time of the year to get an object to catch the light just so. In that mode he is an artist. And I'm sure he has made 1000's (or probably more likely 10's of 1000's) of shots that are somewhere in between.
That’s just silly. If no one can hear the difference then who cares? Why would it even matter what song I was getting tiny snippets from? It’s like asking a specific poet for permission to use a certain word.
> Ok, so I have this little piece of software here, it allows me to extract the notes, durations and volumes of individual notes of a piano piece and then I can re-play those notes using any instrument from an enormous bank of synthesized sounds. Do you feel that this should count as original work because 'it has never existed before' or do you feel that this is a mechanical transformation and that the original creator should be able to sue me for creating a derived work? Does the mechanism of the derivation count?
Does it sound like the same song or not? You know, would someone listen to it and be able to recognize the melody? That’s what matters!
A court, your lawyer, and then finally, you. After all, if there is no audible difference that is exactly what this would hinge on and in the age of digital music it is fairly trivial to prove that something was sampled on snippets as short as a couple of 10's of ms. Whether that amounts to infringement or not is another matter, but to prove it is not all that hard from a technical point of view.
> Does it sound like the same song or not?
No, because the instrument would be changed, the timing could be changed (slowed down, sped up). Even a musician would have a fairly hard time associating a piece manipulated like that with their own work.
> You know, would someone listen to it and be able to recognize the melody?
We could use a melody that is itself in the public domain for this (say, a piece by JS Bach played by some famous pianist). The melody may be PD but the performance definitely is not.
> That’s what matters!
No, what matters is whether or not it crosses the bar for being recognized as an original work, and I don't think it does. But you've got me thinking about this because I've been toying for a long time with the idea to clean up some extremely bad historical recordings of absolute masterpieces and this is one of the reasons I've been holding back from that, the copyright situation around those would be quite murky.
It's 2:20 am here and I really should be getting some Z's, thank you very much for the interesting exchange, much food for thought.
Yes! Always and only! If you are a songwriter then your inputs are a certain ordering of words and sounds. If you dilute those inputs to the point where it indistinguishable you have created a new song!
No, that's not the right criterium. You can create a new song but it may (not will) be classified as a derived work.
Note that in audio it is fairly easy to prove that a part was sampled and unless your samples are pure noise you would most likely not get away with this. Plenty of artists are more than happy to give permission but they are also likely more than happy to sue if you don't ask for it.
And some don't care. But that should not be your assumption.
Using the same words to write a different book is emphatically not the same as using samples of spoken/sung words or played notes or riffs to create another song. These arguments have all been tried in court (see that article linked above) and failed.
And that's where sites like this:
https://www.whosampled.com/Us3/Cantaloop-(Flip-Fantasia)/sam...
come in handy, if you listen to those other songs you'll realize how brilliant this Cantaloop version really is, in spite of being made using a very high fraction of samples from other songs.
But they did credit them, and they did ask for permission.
Finally, it's good form: artists are usually part of the same eco system and you tend to not do to others what you don't want done to you. If you feel that having your artwork sampled for inclusion by SD is the way forward then that should be your right to decide. But not for SD to decide (in my opinion...).
Also, from my time working in the music industry I know for a fact that kick drums and other sounds are taken from songs and used in other songs without permission or attribution all the time and it is done in a manner that is completely kosher because no artists think their artistry extends to someone trying to make the crack of a snare snappier in a mix. The lawyers think otherwise of course. Recognizable bass line? I mean, I guess pay up, but it’s not like the bass player who wrote that bass line in the session will see a dime. He never even got a publishing credit and why would he?
It's pretty thin ice, and if you mess up it will get costly especially with something that sees high rotation.
I’m not talking about even noticeable sampling of a drum hit but the drum hit being used just to add to the existing drum track in the mix.
This is where transformative allowances come in as well, if not logically because no crime can be committed without any evidence.
I mean, IMO, copyrights on music samples are egregious. Hip hop is significantly transformative and was stymied by lawyers for decades. I’m sure that the best hip hop songs were never allowed to be made. I bet someone put together some absolute best of all time bangers with The Beatles, Micheal Jackson and Prince but they couldn’t get the rights. That trade isn’t worth it my opinion. Luckily the visual arts are more open minded. Richard Prince can be an artist by taking someone’s photo, doodling over it, and selling it for millions while owing nothing to the original photographer.
> This is where transformative allowances come in as well, if not logically because no crime can be committed without any evidence.
I really don't share that particular view. Crimes definitely can occur without evidence, there are plenty of examples. The fact that nobody gets convicted, that possibly the crime goes completely undetected does not mean that no crime occurred.
Let me give you one example of how this could happen: I was in charge of the audit of the 'RSB', a system that controlled a few 100B guilders way back in the day, mainframes were in, the PC/AT was 2 and ran at a whopping 8 Mhz and cost as much as a really good second hand car, Madonna releases 'True Blue'. The bank I worked for had for compliance reasons two physically separate entities, one to produce the code and the data, and another to keep track of it.
Initially I worked on the side that did the daily audits to make sure that everything was good. The process was specified thus: you will receive about 1/8th of a cubic meter of large format (132 column) printout at 7:30 AM. You have 30 minutes to manually review this (feel free to use a pocket calculator that can handle 13 digit numbers if you can find one and be sure to let us know where you found it) and release it, you better have a bloody good reason to not release it because it means that technically there is no opening balance for the day if that should happen. Clearly this is impossible, good luck.
On the first day of my new job, at 7:45 I realized that this is completely impossible so I went to see my boss. He told me that in practice the only known way to make sure that the most horrific of errors are caught is to go to the last page of the report first, check the two number all the way at the bottom of that page and see if they match up, this can be done in less than a minute. And if they match - which they always do - you can safely release the system, it's never been wrong.
So much for the oversight department. About a year later I got accepted as a junior programmer on the other side, and guess what, while there was a formal division between the personal side and the business side of the bank you had access to everything. This was well before ISO27001, security was something someone once may have read something about but we mostly focused on physical security. Once you were 'behind the red rope' you could do just about anything. Sure we had logins and passwords. Three letter login, three letter passwords were pretty common. The three letter logins were typically just the initials of the employee because there wasn't room for much more so those were trivial to guess and there was no upper limit on the number of tries on a password. So you could access pretty much all of the code and while there was a test environment there was no code review worth mentioning. And frankly, with very few exceptions most of the programmers weren't all that good. So it would have been trivial to:
- use someone elses account in the right group
- make a bunch of changes to the RSB system
- ensure that the report that went out to the audit department had matching numbers on the last row of the report
- and finally, to trigger all this say a year after leaving the bank
This likely would never have been discovered because their whole idea of threat modeling did not for one second stop and look at the 'rogue employee' angle, it was strictly a single line of defense: to get on to the 'floor' you had to have a badge that allowed access. The badges were an older Motorola system, brown plastic casing with a sticker on the front with your picture on it. Inside was a beefy pickup coil all the way around the case and a board with a little computer on it that would respond to being powered up by sending out a serial stream ID'ing the badge. That was it. No encryption, no challenge/response. And the ID? It could be set with a nice 8 position dip switch. Guess what ID #001 did?
So all of the requirements for an absolutely perfect crime were there, there would be no evidence and yet a crime would have been committed. There were many other such opportunities, that bank really relied way too much on trust and I would not have been surprised to find out that they had been hacked horribly from the inside without being able to point at the culprit.
The bank was founded in 1918, well before the age of computers and it processed a small mountain of paper every day. On that front their procedures were pretty good. But on the digital side they were - frankly - absolutely hopeless. The gear they used then was old enough that some of it was still labelled 'Sperry Rand' which the company was no longer fielding for about a decade at that time. IT was a cost, security non existent and any half competent coder would have seen 1001 possibilities to defraud that bank, and get away with it cleanly. Maybe some even did.
Obviously a witness testimony of a person being tossed into a volcano is evidence of a body, etc.
So maybe they are locking up and trying people in Europe without evidence of crimes as being committed and having people shift the burden of proof to the accused but here in the United States we really do assume that everyone is innocent until proven guilty.
Our courts don’t expect to waste time either. Why would they hear complaints without evidence? Why would they hear a trivial complaint?
Part of the disconnection I have in these conversations is that people skip over the legal details and want to go right to some deep philosophical discussion about originality or justice, which is fine, but also super annoying because our legal system has developed a pretty sophisticated understanding of those concepts through literal millennia of trial and error.
The current legal system works so much better than whatever I hear commonly described in these comments. If you let nerds get involved the courts would be nothing but people nitpicking over the finest of useless details in some vain attempt to score argument points, as if they’ve been trained on upvotes for decades.
There’s real wisdom in legal practice and I’m always going to lean heavily on those practices when talking about legal matters like copyright.
Originality in art is a different conversation entirely and frankly even if the courts want to view 10ms audio samples as worthy of copyright (which I’m pretty sure they would not concern themselves with), from an artistic standpoint I’m fully onboard with the idea that the musician who chopped up that sample into indistinguishable parts and then made new music is the sole author of an original work.
Ethically, copyright goes too far the moment is begins to choke the public domain and that yes, this weighs the needs of a given individual against anyone else. I’m sure the first person to record a I-IV-V progression would prefer to get a dollar every time a future composer used that but that would clearly be stifling to art in general. Copyright law in the US has evolved to capture this same ethical understanding and it’s not the only embedded wisdom.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_conviction_without_a_bo...
Other observations about how legal systems elsewhere work are ignored on account of the opening sentence.
So at this point have you run out of any ammo other than meaningless nitpicks?
Both show that there is no intent for individual infringement, with along with no infringing material being produced and the significant non-infringing commercial use like family photo touch-ups, it makes for a very strong narrative for the defense!
To change lanes to art for a second…
When I’m using a tool like Logic I can coax drums, Hammond Organ, 70s analog synths, out of my laptop. I can’t make any of those sounds with my body. I need a tool.
Without Logic I would have to own a drum kit (which I happen to do), know how to play it, know how to record it… with logic I just click a dozen times and I’ve got a drummer playing four-on-the-floor.
So when I do work with a real drummer don’t tell them exactly what to play on a grid like with a drum sampler in Logic, rather they just listen in contribute. Logic has a virtual drummer that does basically the same.
How different is it to fire up another piece of software and employ a virtual painter?
Ok, shift back over to technology and creative work… what are the pros and cons of drum samplers? Don’t they put drummers out of business? Isn’t the trade-off that now a lot more people have access to nice sounding drums and that the world has more music?
This is provably false: if any specific piece can be removed and there is no difference then you can keep doing that until there is no art left. I'd bet a very substantial amount of money that the output at that point will definitely have changed. Induction is a powerful thing.
Or if we want to do thought experiments, randomly remove any thousand images and the tool is still just as useful. If it’s random, not specific images, that are removed, then it is non-specific images that power the tool… yes, millions of those images, so a specific quantity is required but no specific works.
It is possible for a prompt to create a copyright violation, just like if I recreate an existing iconic drum loop it would be. But, just because a tool can infringe doesn't mean the tool itself is infringing.
That's fair. But if you would sample Phil Collins (just to name one famous drummer) to create a Phil Collins sample pack and you'd then create your own drum loop with it that wouldn't mean you can't expect some expensive mail incoming. And it will likely stick.
The easiest way to create original art without having this shadow hanging over you would be to make your own sounds, use licensed sounds or to attempt to license the sounds you want to use (but that are not available for public use). Any other path is likely going to be a legal minefield and may lead to you losing your rep and a bunch of $.
There are plenty of examples of people that did this, went to court and lost.
What is original to begin with? What's original about Bob Dylan's Blowin in the Wind? Certainly not the form! It's a standard AB folk song. Certainly not the chords! The melody? Sure, but very bounded by Western music theory and containing a number of common American melodic tropes. The words and specific rhymes have all be used before in previous poems and light verse. He used a standard 6-string guitar with standard tuning with standard guitar chords that have been strummed in similar patterns on hundreds if not thousands of previous recordings.
Beyond the technical skill required to create something there's nothing left but just a series of choices about how to rearrange what culture has provided for you. A truly original work would be incomprehensible to an audience in a way that a truly original language would be incomprehensible to an audience. The originality, the agency of the artist, stems from the choices being made, regardless of if that tool simulates a drummer based on the placement of notes on a grid or if that tool simulates a photographer based on the input of some key words.
Now, you can certainly say that if everyone has access to Stable Diffusion that the value of its output is relatively diminished and that is of course true. The same thing happened to drum machines. No one is that impressed by a four-on-the-floor beat coming out of a laptop and they soon won't be impressed by simulated painters but this is on a different axis of examination than originality.
The fact that he claims he made it, and that this went uncontested for decades is fairly strong proof that it really is his.
But I thought you were interested in originality outside of just the legal perspective? You know, that crimes can be committed without evidence and all?
What makes Blowing in the Wind different from another folk song of the time? What makes them the same? Why are some non-original aspects allowed in a work considered original?