They even address this at the begining of the post:
>Nobody really likes C++ or CMake, and there's no clear path for getting off old toolchains. Every year the pain will get worse.
>C++ is becoming a legacy language and finding contributors in the future will become difficult
Dealing with a large C++ code bases and CMake build errors is about as fun as getting kicked in the head.
If Fish was a business and their entire focus was the bottom line, then it'd be a different conversation.
Rust projects seem to always be extremely easy to compile, make use of common shared libraries, and shared patterns. Once you learn the language, you need to know little about the individual project like you do with C/++ projects.
Well, that and you get stuff like fs::read(path) instead of always having to go find the ReadFile function from the last project you worked on like in C++ land.
To add to this point, I used to work at a large-ish C++ shop and we were already having problems finding C++ developers years ago and I'm assuming its just getting worse.
But when you add it all up, it makes Fish delightful in a way that no other shell quite is just yet.
I'd say it looks like they want to bring some of the same philosophy to their own toolchain and source code. It's about making Fish more delightful, just for developers this time rather than just end users.
I'm optimistic that the Fish maintainers will be right this time, too. And at the end of the day, hell— it's their project, it should stay fun for that. As long as they don't break my usage too badly, I prefer that they rewrite Fish in whatever way keeps its development joyful for them. (I trust them on this. It's a small team maintaining a project they clearly love, and I think they have the chops.)
On a related note, I’ve been really happy with the project’s release / update cadence. It seems like every few months a new feature or refactor drops that makes my life easier. It’s just such a great tool, and such a well-governed project.
Maybe Rust is equally hard and slow to write, but at least the result generates fewer CVEs.