And car registration numbers and passport numbers and street addresses are also personal identifiable information despite the fact that people does not have those either. Just like IP addresses. This is a good thing.
> Personal data is not defined in terms of the context in which it appears
This is a good thing because it closes a dozen loopholes and allows good-faith actors to remain on the right side of the law without much effort.
> if you have someone's personal data and you are told to stop processing it, you must stop processing it. But storage, erasure and transmission are all classed as processing, and it's logically impossible not to do at least one of these things
This just shows a poor understanding of the law, or you are just hand-waving things you have no knowledge about. This is not how the GDPR works. At all.