Note that I’m not commenting on how high performers are doing in terms of getting new jobs! It could be bad, it could be good, I don’t know.
But layoffs with less worker protections have always been the trade-off for higher compensation for top performers. Just because the understood risk occurred doesn’t mean that it was a bad risk to take, or even that it was much of a risk at all (especially if top performers have emergency funds that tide them over to their next job)!
All this to say that your rebuttal to the high performer argument isn’t super convincing. I’m sure it could be made better, but as it stands it’s not offering much.