yeah, it's totally a self own but it gets paraded around a lot like it proves something which it clearly doesn't.
It proves the guy is blatantly dishonest, no?
Does it? It really just shows that he wasn't serious when he said he'd literally dirk it. I wouldn't assume that was a serious statement. A more careful person would have said something like "you could hypothetically drink the stuff and based on everything we know right now you'd be just fine."