Hacker News Reader

Comment by conesus | Hacker News Reader

You might be interested in postgresql's hstore: http://www.postgresql.org/docs/9.0/static/hstore.html

It's a key-value store that allows querying, which is what I think you are lamenting in your comment. Here's a bit more about how to query and index with hstore: http://lwn.net/Articles/406385/. It's pretty simple and doesn't have anywhere near the number of querying possibilities that MongoDB has, but it can be used for on-the-fly column names (similar to JSON). You can only query on the root node's children, unlike the open-ended possibilities in NoSQL.

View on HN

Oh, that is very intersting, thanks!

I'm (quite happily) tied to Postgres because I'm using PostGIS, but the ability to add freeform data to a location would be ideal. Looks like I may already have a solution here.

@scorpioxy -- I can't reply to you directly, but you've been [dead] for a few months now. I see you've posted quality comments, but you posted what could be perceived as a spam post 138 days ago and so you got marked as a spambot. But you're clearly not. Might want to clear that up, but for now, you're dead when you probably ought to not be.

With hstore and psycopg, you'd gain a lot of flexibility that's very similar to another NoSql store. Psycopg does the mapping to/from python dicts.

It's not without a learning curve, but I found it helpful when I hit shortcomings in Mongo's design.

Cool, PostGIS! What are you building? I worked as GIS engineer in 2010. PostGIS is pretty cool technology.

I'm building a 'taxi tracker' app, for want of a better term- gives you estimated trip times, allows you to share the journey with other people so they know where you are.

That part doesn't require PostGIS as such, but it's for an NYC city government app competition, so we have all sort of city datasets to use. I've used PostGIS to help make custom map tiles (preview at https://twitter.com/#!/taxonomyapp/status/149565007384940545), highlight the outline of the building you're heading to... all sorts. It's been a fantastic learning exercise.

I don't know exactly what your GIS needs are, but it might be worth seeing if MongoDB's geospatial indexing meets them if you are interested in querying free-form data.

http://www.mongodb.org/display/DOCS/Geospatial+Indexing http://www.mongodb.org/display/DOCS/Geospatial+Haystack+Inde...

As someone who is building a similar app, for a similar competition (but in Boston):

Don't combine your data structures / stores. Use the store / structure that is most appropriate for the given task. Memory is cheap vs compute time.

Hint: many can be only in memory stores that periodically sync to a backing store for updates.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com