In a typical F500 setting strategy consultants aren’t on-hand to make anything better or improve anything meaningfully - in general consultants are on hand to validate a C or C-1’s personal belief and drive its execution. Why?
First, this is what keeps these companies around. You don’t keep a client by telling them they’re wrong or ignorant. Two, buying the big three name is essentially idea laundering. “It’s not a land grab, Bain said said we had to do it.” “McKinsey told us we had to hollow out that one plant town to survive!” They’re also an emotional refuge and a great backchannel. The BCG principal talks to the CEO weekly, you might not, good to be on their good side.
Look, I’m sure in certain niche, high-skill consultants (industrial process engineering?) are valuable. By random dart method they’ve probably driven a fair amount of value, but on average you should never let them in the door.