I sometimes need to extend a system like this from one site to another. One is a calrec system (an audio mixer, I think it's the control traffic that needs to be sent), and I don't have enough access or time to see if I could build some kind of transparent proxy -- it won't work with multicast routing.
I do however have enough time to create a layer2 network between two nics. I tend to use mikrotiks for that, create an eoip tunnel (GRE with proprietary addons to cope with fragmentation) between the two endpoints and pop the interface in a bridge with a physical port, and move on.
"You don't need to do that thing."
How do you know?
Edit: I see you changed your comment to consider remote DHCP which causes my comment above to be irrelevant. Oh well. The fact still holds that VXLAN is meant to handle Layer 2 so saying BGP is an alternative is like putting a square peg in a round hole.
For QoS, what do you think double-encapsulating all of the QoS bits inside of two tunnels is going to do for you? If you pay your carrier to respect QoS, you have to actually give them the bits! QoS goes on the OUTSIDE of the onion.
DHCP for VLANs should be handled by snooping for it on the switch and forwarding over L3 (ip helper-address), not by running vxlan over a VPN tunnel. And really it shouldn't ever be done over a potentially unreliable WAN link either; you should have a local agent for DDI at each site.
The only story here is that L2-over-L3 VPN have their very specific niches, and VXLAN+Wireguard is an alternative to L2TP+IPSec that is (IMO) both easier to configure and more reliable when such a thing is needed.
I'm sorry to ask but which alternative do you find easier and more reliable? I seem to be able to parse that either way, maybe it's just me.
Nope, here with the same problem and I don't treat L2TP/IPSec as an easier to configure and reliable.
L2 connectivity is still quite useful, even if you don't have a need for it.