Citation needed.
Are you seriously asking them for a citation on their own opinion?
In your opinion, it's akin to BMW's heated seats subscription.
On the face of it, whether I agree or disagree, the first opinion at least makes more sense.
Since both are opinions, "citation needed" is a non sequitur. Or do you have citations for your opinion?
If there would be a significant competition without a subscription: yes, people would keep on complaining.
If everybody would jump on the train: probably no, because people would have forgotten what "normal" was.
I find option 2 quite unlikely so the answer to your question is: yes.
And yet, in a world filled with actors with malicious intent - cybercriminals, spammers, secret services, dark spyware vendors, scammers cashing in on "popular" brands or sometimes outright cloning applications - it is the only way to enforce some honesty.
I don't like it either, but I do not see an alternative.