Yes it is, because the State decided to censor and restrict 'free speech' in that case.
>I think you are smart enough to understand the difference between free speech and plotting a murder.
Sure, I'm very open to my belief we should censor and punish some speech. I just wanted to establish that you do support censorship and you do believe that sometimes saying 'don't let those words affect you' isn't an appropriate reaction.
>Who do we give the power of deciding what speech is banned in modern day America?
That power already resides with Congress and then hypothetically the Supreme Court. Functioning democracies can have conversations and then decide when, where, and how to restrict speech. We've been doing that for 250 years.
>I just don't think anyone in the United States should have the power to ban ideas.
We've already established that you think the government can and should restrict ideas. 'Free speech absolutist' are rarely actually absolutist.