The interesting part is why are they all in sync, and fairly similar in size. Did they really all make the same mistake in the past? Was the groupthink/copycat happening during the over-hire phase?
The interesting part is why are they all in sync, and fairly similar in size. Did they really all make the same mistake in the past? Was the groupthink/copycat happening during the over-hire phase?
Having said that, the layoffs are not happening in a vacuum, there's been significant economic issues over the past year and cash isn't basically free anymore. Some companies may have made moonshot efforts hoping to be at the front of <now essential industry> with the pandemic but things largely went back to normal.
But it's likely not just one factor. I'd believe that:
1. Some companies are bloated and can (maybe should) downsize, or over-invested in projects that didn't pan out.
2. Some companies care more about costs now than they did a year ago (for reasons good or bad)
3. Some companies are more willing to conduct large layoffs since other large ones are doing it and it looks better
4. Some companies are facing pressure from investors to cut costs and do layoffs because "other bigs ones did it"
All can be true for some sets of companies - there isn't going to be "just one reason" why all a company decides to do layoffs.
So many potential reasons, including:
- "If we're to do it, let's do it now, while we're still in the wake of Twitter and other big companies, and thus shielded from bad press".
- Some company's management was considering a layoff for quite a while, but worried it might be too damaging or too difficult. Seeing other similar companies doing their own layoffs without much effort or negative impact would relieve the management's fears, and lead them to staging their own layoff. Now imagine there were a lot of companies that independently overhired, then started thinking about "cutting the fat", and all got - again, independently - blocked by the same set of worries. This threshold is a sync point. Everyone may arrive at it on their own, but they cross it simultaneously.
I loathe Zuckerberg but his insistence that managers contribute or leave is exactly what my org needs. Unfortunately this is the sort of change that’s basically impossible when so many people’s power is vested in it not happening.
As I read the title, that is what it says. It does not say, e.g., "The widespread layoffs are because of copycat behaviour not cost cutting". It says
"The widespread layoffs are more because of copycat behaviour than cost-cutting".
To me the interesting part is that with all the coordinated layoffs, so far the public1 generally sees no "decline in service", assuming these companies claim to be providing services to the public.2 That implies these were, as Graeber would put it, bullshit jobs.
"Tech" companies are not known for original thinking. Knee-jerk, copycat behaviour can be seen in everything they do.
1. By "public" I mean the ad targets, aka "users", not the advertisers.
2. Twitter being a notable exception.
...on the scale of a few months, maybe. There are a lot of activities that are essential to the long term health of the organization that can be abandoned for a little while: developing future innovative product lines, keeping infrastructure well maintained, having a full QA process compared to cutting corners, customer service tools and roles, etc.
The the point upstream about Musk is real. Companies like Google established that you need to hire 10x rockstars or whatever, and pay ludicrous salaries. The growth curve is going to slow, and the money people aren’t gonna want to pay the wacky salaries for people.
As to the in sync part, the most plausible explanation is the economy. Inflation from the Russian-Ukranian war plus Covid stimulus drove the Fed to boost the interest rate.
The similar size bit is more difficult, but if a lot of that is support staff like recruiting, then that may make more sense, if those staffing levels were based on the number of engineering headcount in the first place.
R&D, marketing, even good customer service all allow you to grow next year but firing them allows you to return more money now.