Most of it is pattern recognition and learning common idioms, like multiplying by 0x01010101..., extracting substrings of bits ((x >> y) & z), thinking of values as sets of integers and so on.
Also bitwise manipulations lend themselves well to function composition, so try to keep an eye out for that. For example, if you have a fast function that checks if any byte is zero, you can generalize it to any value by applying xor beforehand. Similarly, the fast bit matrix transpose (which absolutely terrified me) is simply applying the least number of "shift a subset of bits" operations such that each bit travels the required distance.
It sounds a little woo-woo but going from representing something on paper (or worse, a display) to doing it with my hands really changed it for me. Humans likely evolved intelligence because we stood up and used our hands to manipulate our environment, I suspect we more fully engage our brains in important ways by doing something with our hands when we can.
You might start appreciating the imperial system of measurement though. You've been warned.
E.g in decimal you can multiply by ten by appending a zero, so in binary you multiply by 2 by doing so. And left shifting by 1 is what appends a zero.
Or you can take approximate log base ten in decimal by counting amount of digits, so in binary you can approximate log2 this way (counting up to most significant one-bit). Etc...