Hacker News Reader

Comment by profstasiak | Hacker News Reader

can you share what made you drop the smartphone? I wish my kids were like you and would like to push them in this direction

View on HN

> can you share what made you drop the smartphone?

Sure, there were a few factors that made me not keep one:

Firstly, I’ve never been that active on social media platforms such as Instagram, Snapchat etc. I did have an account for a short period of time, but I noticed there’s really not much of value Im missing out on. 99% of teenage group chats are about teenage crushes and general high school drama which isn’t something Im much interested in. Ditching the smartphone thus didn’t really affect my communication with my friends.(I might have missed out on the popular kids parties though :P)

Then there’s also the problem that I found myself getting distracted and procrastinating on school-work which was affecting my productivity.

It wasn't an easy and I did have withdrawal symptoms initially, but I do think I'm able to focus more now for longer intervals and more ‘present’. I did receive a lot of derision from my friends, though.

>I wish my kids were like you and would like to push them in this direction

You could maybe talk to them about whether they think it’s having a negative impact on them and what do they think they can to do reduce it. If its not mutually agreed upon it will be difficult to work on it.

> You could maybe talk to them about whether they think it’s having a negative impact on them and what do they think they can to do reduce it. If its not mutually agreed upon it will be difficult to work on it.

Are you sure you're 17 haha? You sound more mature than many adults.

Thanks! probably a consequence of hanging out on HN :P

I got told this a lot when I was 15. It doesn't seem to take much for a teenager to sound more mature than many adults. :)

It does not…

It’s your job. You don’t “push” your kids. You instruct them, set expectations, and enforce the expected behavior.

General advice for kids and phones:

- no phones before 12 yr old

- shared phones between 12-16 (with other siblings or the “house” cell phone that also can be used by parents)

- own phone once 16 to acclimate them to healthy use while under your roof.

- a phone box for everyone in the household that gets used between 6-10pm every day (eg phone lives in the box, can still be checked if rings but then goes back in box not pocket)

- punishments that involve loss of phone privileges. This should follow the “x7 rule” where the punishment is much more severe than the disobedience (eg don’t listen to parent, 3 days without phone)

- model good behavior yourself. No phone out when your kids are around.

> model good behavior yourself. No phone out when your kids are around.

This is probably the most important part (and the hardest, for a lot of people).

>shared phones between 12-16 (with other siblings or the “house” cell phone that also can be used by parents)

lol good luck trying to enforce that when almost every 12 year old kid has their own smartphone today. 'Your' kid will most certainly feel left-out,different and noticed and will be commented on by their friends.

> model good behavior yourself. No phone out when your kids are around.

Yeah I dont think this is a really effective way to go about this, sure I get your point, but parents(or adults in general), have way more responsibilities and pressing matters to attend to. Not saying thats always the case, but its an apples to oranges comparison here.

Liked your other comments but this one was disappointing. Kids would eat ice cream for all meals if you let them. But they don’t because parents say no. “Lol good luck… other kids” is not an appropriate response to that duty.

That said, the lockbox part is not practical I think. More workable is to avoid data plans and use screen time/cut wifi outside core hours.

> punishments that involve loss of phone privileges. This should follow the “x7 rule” where the punishment is much more severe than the disobedience (eg don’t listen to parent, 3 days without phone)

I'm a strict parent, but... what?

This is a thing. I grew up in a conservative Christian family and saw some of this. For some families (not mine) punishment was considered the primary tool of teaching. As the Bible says: spare the rod, spoil the child.

What most people don't seem to know is the "rod" isn't something you're supposed to hit a sheep with. You nudge and guide them with it.

You've described child abuse.

Not giving unrestricted access to a smartphone to a child is child abuse? GTFO.

It's not about a smartphone, you're welcome.

How does a consequence that's deliberately disproportionate to what they've done teach children anything? Are you trying to prepare your children for the world, or to ensure they correspond to some ideal you have imagined?

Good points, I'd add since a lot of kids these days have technology in general and are incorporating in some schooling and such you can add a device for single-purpose use, i.e iPad for reading, watching, demo-ing, etc. with structured timing like phone box, shared times, etc.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com