It’s going to be a shit show. But heh, at least those pesky pensions went away, amirite? Insolvent pensions are the least of your concerns when tens of millions of older Americans have a vote and are collecting an entitlement till death.
It’s going to be a shit show. But heh, at least those pesky pensions went away, amirite? Insolvent pensions are the least of your concerns when tens of millions of older Americans have a vote and are collecting an entitlement till death.
The problem isn't retirement accounts, it's a lack of mandatory funding by employers.
Even a 2500/year contribution for a worker will yield almost 200k at a 2% annual return on an average and almost 500k at a 5% return over 45 years. While by no means could independently support a lifestyle, it can definitely supplement social security. The burden for workers to save would be significantly lower.
Not only must employer contributions be mandated, but it must be very hard to get access to the funds before retirement. Otherwise, they’re just cashed out. You also have to have strong guardrails around fees and fiduciaries so it’s not a big pot of money for finance to leach off of.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superannuation_in_Australia
Also agree with Retric’s sibling comment.
We don’t use that system because individual 401k’s are extremely profitable for the companies running them. Fees can reduce the long term payout by as much as 1/3.
Best to go into a self directed account and use Vanguard and safe yourself thousands in fees over a lifetime.
You're absolutely right about pensions though; people pining for the days of the fixed benefit pension rarely are all that familiar with the pension plans that simply went bust due to inability to fund their liabilities due to market conditions. At least with a 401(k), you're not running out of money because your retirement is being invested too conservatively so as to pay someone older than you, leaving it empty by the time it's your turn.
I cannot imagine relying on a company to pay me during retirement. I get that that system existed once, but the incentives are so misaligned it terrifies me
Another game was simply redefining the terms, almost always reducing the benefits. This was a common game and it's almost irresistible to the managers. At the highest level, the US government is always doing when they tweak the Social Security formulas for retirement age.
At least with the 401k/IRA/SEP etc, you're in control and you see the assets go up or down.
A is broken because it cause B and C. replace A with X, which cause C and Z, with Z being as bad as B but a million times harder to fix.
This was the problem, not lack of defined benefit pensions. With the advent of near zero cost target date retirement funds and equity and bond index funds, there is no need to be beholden to one employer and have to trust the pension plan trustees with your retirement.
Best case scenario is the trustees invest in the same index funds you would, and worst case is they misappropriate the funds or take wild risks. So why not cut out the unnecessary middleman?
If you really want an annuity, then buy it from an actually regulated insurance company, rather than a DB pension plan that is doing who knows what.