That said, I'm guilty of the occasional "I agree" reply like that, and it typically gets downvoted -- as it should.
Acknowledging something is fine if you then talk to that person but most people replaced the conversation with the like.
While it's nice to see "number go up" from the upvotes on my comments, that simply doesn't have the same value to me as having the conversation move forward.
Sadly, Hacker News isn't the best place to have conversations. Threads can start fast on 1st page articles, run up a bunch of comments, and then the discussion dries up within hours. Ugh.
edit- specifically, I'm thinking of politically-minded forums where the top comments are just comments that reinforce the accepted mentality without really challenging anybody's ideas