It's not that different from existing ad-hoc systems for dealing with CSAM, like the IWF in the UK. And it will be within the exemptions of Article 10 ECHR. The only country that might object is Germany.
It's not that different from existing ad-hoc systems for dealing with CSAM, like the IWF in the UK. And it will be within the exemptions of Article 10 ECHR. The only country that might object is Germany.
This is potentially evil, no matter how trusted a state (thinks) it is.
The status of ‘trusted flagger’ under this Regulation shall be awarded, upon application by any entity, by the Digital Services Coordinator of the Member State in which the applicant is established, to an applicant that has demonstrated that it meets all of the following conditions:
(a)
it has particular expertise and competence for the purposes of detecting, identifying and notifying illegal content;
(b)
it is independent from any provider of online platforms;
(c)
it carries out its activities for the purposes of submitting notices diligently, accurately and objectively.
For example, do you think it is more evil that Google can ban you for any reason without telling you why, or the government being able to ban you while stating exactly why and you having legal rights? I think the first is worse than the second, so moving from the first to the second is a positive development.
Surely you can imagine the possibility of us coming up with systems and processes that are both non-anarchic as well as different from what we have today.
See this thread where he extolled the virtues of confining people who didn't get the covid vaccine to their homes, and insisted that natural immunity wasn't a thing:
They can sue and arrest people who publish, not play ducking big brother
Removing content by government insiders has only been done in authoritarian countries
Edit: Think the Twitter files, with how the American government flags content on Twitter and then Twitter bans it. USA already has that trusted flagging system, but under the hood so you don't see it. I don't see why moving that to the open would be any worse.
Yes this is pretty much what it is, and now it is a legal requirement, and the request by the government have to be prioritized and processed 'without delay'.
And if the government abuses the requests, then the website can complain to ... the government.
I don't understand why you think this is normal. it is not. This "government unable to stop itself" is precisely the reason why press freedom was written into constitutions
Much of EU doesn't rank low in corruption. What this means is, every 4 years the new government will be re-staffing the "national censorship service" (Digital Services Coordinator ) with its cronies. The countries which need free press the most will be affected for the worse
But Google could challenge that to the EU court, and the EU court isn't full of Bulgarian cronies. Or do you think that the EU court would take the side of Bulgarian cronies, really?
If Bulgaria wanted to censor the internet they would already have their own laws to do it. As you said, only extremely authoritarian countries censors the way you describe here, I doubt Bulgaria would get away with it, they would get kicked out of EU if they start to create a CCP style big brother state.
(I used Bulgaria as an example since it is ranked the most corrupt country in EU)
PS. You can't "force" anything to go to the ECJ, only national courts decide. EU law is integrated into local law
EU directives are turned into national laws.
> This is potentially evil, no matter how trusted a state (thinks) it is.
Is this worse than a company doing it? Right now there is practically 0 accountability and 0 recourse for corporate internet moderation.
Any group with an ideological bent, or an agenda can set themselves up as agents for monitoring "dangerous" content. They may even do that job for the stuff we want actually policed, but they'll also do things like remove all negative mentions of Xi Jinping, or any rumblings against the new Soma product...
A company does it on their own service. You go to another. A government sanctioned agent can do it to all services.
you can choose another company, you can't choose another government, and it can imprison you
This is just capitalist utopia, capitalism tends toward monopolies/duopolies by itself - it is precisely the governments job to create an order in which fair competition can continue. Having a more or less democratically elected body help with the tyranny of these few megacorps is absolutely essential.
It's defined as cruel and oppressive government or rule.