It would be interesting to hear Panic's input here. They're a long-time Mac studio, surely they've got some suggestions for regulators.
It would be interesting to hear Panic's input here. They're a long-time Mac studio, surely they've got some suggestions for regulators.
Cabel Sasser emailed Phil Schiller ideas on the app review process in 2016. A good chunk of it wound up getting implemented. I'd love to see a sequel.
Unrelatedly, I think the tone in his email is a perfect example of giving successful constructive criticism.
It did?
1) "When we decided to pull Coda from the App Store (due to sandboxing)"
Sandboxing is still required.
2) "we regained our ability to release software the moment we need to"
Nope, nothing has changed there.
3) "we could fill a small book with frustrating and tragicomic App Review anecdotes"
This was written before the Untitled Goose Game rejections.
4) "Reviews are often the dumping ground of the uninformed"
Still painfully true!
5) Refunds: "And when this happens, we can do nothing."
Still true. Developers can't issue their own refunds, and the App Store doesn't even have an official refund policy. I've been seeing more and more people get their App Store refund requests rejected by Apple, for no apparent reason.
6) Low app prices
Still a problem of course!
[0] https://developer.apple.com/app-store/ratings-and-reviews/
After their initial announcement of the policy, Apple clarified that they would still reject bugfixes if the app violated section 5 of the guidelines, the section titled "Legal". On the surface, this would seem reasonable. After all, can't go violating legal requirements. However, this is still counter to the spirit of what they had promised. If it's up on the store already, if it's violating the law (e.g. for scamming users out of money), it should be taken down. If it's not violating the law, it's better that customers get the bugfix.
They also copied a bunch of rules from the other sections into section 5, to give themselves more leeway.
https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/#leg...
This was just about the least Apple could do. You can't have a conversation, you can only post one reply. And in my experience, App Store reviewers almost never correct their bad reviews, even if you reply with info that will fix their problem.
> Apple moved away from the "no refunds" policy
Apple still has no official refund policy. You can request a refund, which Apple may or may not grant, as I mentioned, at Apple's own discretion, for any reason or no reason. So I don't see how anything has changed from Cabel's email.
> completely stopped holding up bug fixes over guideline infractions
Completely wrong. What happens is that App Review still rejects your bug fix updates. But then you can request that App Review let your update go through, and fix the problem in the next update. The problem is that this can still take an indefinite amount of time, because App Review can reject you at any time, even when you're asleep, then you have to contact them, then they have to see your message and respond, all of which can take half a day or more. It's a joke. We're still delayed.
The other day my app got a 1-star customer review titled "Monthly subscriptions ain't it" and saying "0/5 now that it's subscription based."
My app is not subscription based, it's upfront paid.
This is the crap that developers have to deal with all the time in the App Store.
The crowdsourced rating/review system is a blight.
Nothing about apples behavior is "win win". They're a corp that benefits from special protections against both civil and criminal liabilities as well as benefitting from masses of intellectual property. It's not some sort of balanced game, the scales were tipped completely into corpo land since early 2000s
I guess even when Apple close all the loopholes to running "unauthorized" software there will be people silly enough to buy their computers.
You help build one walled garden, you get kicked out of another.
The Mac App Store is not a monopoly. Mac developers can independently distribute their apps.
As I mentioned, Mac developers can independently distribute their own apps, signed with a Developer ID certificate.
It's annoying to be sure, but not a major hurdle for professional Mac developers, such as Panic.
It's fascinating you made a 180 on the issue while it got worse since you wrote it.
I could bet that in under 5 years Apple will refuse to "notarize" at least some software and prevent unsigned software from running altogether.
How so?
Now you're saying it's all good. Go figure.
I've been philosophically opposed to Gatekeeper since its introduction more than 10 years ago, and that hasn't changed.
The mostly good news is that Apple mostly doesn't prevent non-malware developers from distributing their apps on the Mac. I'm aware of only 2 cases where Apple has intentionally abused its authority there: (1) Apple canceled the developer account of Epic Games after the famous trial. (2) Apple canceled the developer account of Kapeli after an allegation of App Store review fraud. However, the account was later restored, and Dash for Mac is currently signed and notarized. https://kapeli.com/dash
A monopoly is not defined by 100% control. It is defined by whom has the overwhelming control.
You can do so the same way you always could. Perhaps you're mixing it up with ARM Macs requiring code to be signed by something? (it doesn't have to be by an Apple certificate). You can still run self-signed code on macOS even with Apple Silicon and the latest OS versions and there's no sign they'll ever change that. Our distribution tool Conveyor will self-sign apps for you out of the box and create a web page that tells users what to do [1], albeit we should make it less wordy.
> Apple developer license is apart of the app store
A Developer ID is separate from the app store, they're different certificate types. I distribute Mac software outside the store with one, no problem.
[1] example: https://downloads.hydraulic.dev/eton-sample/selfsigned/downl...
Which makes sense, if all I had to do is sign some malware, that doesn't prevent me from spreading malware.
So if there is some method of this, it would be cool to know. I'll have to do some experiments.
Government regulators aren't going to get involved over $100.
> As of Ventura you cannot bypass gatekeeper without a signature for a number of popular solutions. Electron being one of them.
I'm not sure what you mean. I'm not sure you technically understand what you mean.
Mac Ventura only allows for "App store and identified developers". Meaning the application must be signed with an apple developer cert to go through gatekeeper.
This has nothing to do with Ventura. It's been true for many years.
Keep in mind that I am personally a professional Mac developer. You're out of your depth here.
EDIT: Guys, you can literally just install using Steam or Epic. It's really not a problem.
This whole strange fascination with claiming Apple is a monopoly is just silly. There is at least one major competitor to Apple in the mobile market (said competitor actually dominates that market by a huge margin) and literally dozens in the PC market. Apple isn't a monopoly, and it doesn't have to let competitors distribute their products within its own ecosystem.
Let's keep following in this thread. So if Ford created a 3rd-party battery pack, Tesla isn't legally allowed to prevent customers from replacing their battery pack with the Ford (or an Our Next Energy (ONE), who actually sells a) pack. Similarly, Ford has no legal standing to stop you if you buy a gasoline F-150, gut the motor and fuel tank, and install a Tesla motor and battery from a salvage title Model S.
This goes even further. The Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act from 1975 explicitly says Tesla isn't allowed to deny warranty coverage just because you used aftermarket or recycled parts, or went to a non-Tesla authorized auto shop for routine maintenance or repairs.
You don't own the iPhone you paid for, and the inability to install apps, with root permissions, is reason number 1 why. Meanwhile, you can actually take a wrench to a Ford F-150 all you want.
Not really. The point is less about market positioning and more about building fair platforms. Apple wants to frame themselves as an underdog competitor in the global economy, but they fail because they can't even build a fair or open platform when given total freedom to do so. This "failure" has made them a lot of money, but it's also come to the detriment of users everywhere, whether they know it or not. The law exists explicitly to push companies like Apple along when they get too fat and rest on their Carnegie laurels.
> The alternatives to going through the App Store are really not viable.
Someone ought to tell the Mac people this, they'll be heartbroken.
> In this one small market Apple exerts its market dominance influence to take a lot of money from 3rd party developers. Of course this is small potatoes compared to all the other markets that they compete in and even as a fraction of their revenue.
Last year Apple made more from services than they did from iPhone hardware. That's not just a "fraction" anymore.
I guess it's not exactly a laptop monopoly, but a walled laptop monopoly alright.
Regulators?
On iOS, if Apple's store rejected them, there's no recourse. Apple blocks other stores from existing, and there's no competition in distribution, review, and of course payments and the cut.
Which is why I was asking about regulators.
> On iOS if Apple's store rejects you, that's game over.
Everyone knows this, it doesn't need to be said. But fewer people are familiar with the Mac situation.