If 70% of depositors withdrew before the bank went into receivership there is nothing left.
And the assets they held were primarily treasury securities and MBS. Why would anyone sell those “on the cheap” when the market is super liquid?
If there were assets on the books left, the gov't could purchase them at face value and just hold to maturity.
The solution is to wipe out the SVB shareholders, that's the only way to make sure other banks don't have an incentive to do these things. Then pay the startups whatever part of the funds you can recover on the market (may be close to 90% if some comes from SVB shareholders).
The VCs may have to step in at a few companies for loosing 10%, but that's likely the ones that weren't doing great anyway.
Using tax payer money to save SVB shareholders and some VCs is ridiculous. These guys have enough money, they're all professionals, it's a risk they took and unfortunately they lost this round. Better luck next time.
It is in the governments best interest for people to have faith in banks, regardless of what industry they serve. The FDIC was created because a run on one bank, once it becomes public knowledge, always turns into a run on more banks. They don't want this turning into a line of dominoes.
The biggest risk is that this leads to runs on other banks. People are already looking pretty closely at a few others like First Republic. Deposit insurance exists to reassure people that they won't lose their money, to reduce the temptation to start a bank run.
The workers who might not get their next paychecks or could lose their jobs entirely are not to blame for the problem either.
VCs will be fine no matter what happens, because they are billionaires. Trying to hurt them will fail and will result in other people getting hurt too. Moral outrage shouldn't be used as an excuse to make a bad problem worse.
Because then even more people that did not cause this would be paying for it.
A contact who has a college friend who works(/ed?) at SVB as a client service rep says that they were "specifically instructed to make or accept zero communications, emails, or phone calls with SVB clients."
What due diligence can seriously be carried out by Monday/Tuesday? Especially for a messy "acquisition" like this one.
They understand timing is really important to rescue these banks, they need to get stability ASAP or tons of value gets destroyed. Potential buyers know this too.