It's not number on the clock. It's the switching.
People would still have to deal with the change either way.
In northern latitudes there aren’t enough daylight hours for a full working day to be between sunrise and sunset. That’s the immutable constraint - everything else is to deal with that.
Also, we see frequent posts here on HN about how schools ought to start later overall, for all students, so it seems reasonable to think that school could be made to start well after sunrise for everyone all year long.
Making school start Larter in general is a hard problem because there is only one real option and nobody likes it
https://www.washingtonian.com/2022/03/15/the-us-tried-perman...
https://www.npr.org/2022/03/19/1087280464/the-u-s-tried-perm...
It takes about a generation for people to forget about how bad the DST approach is. If it is to be locked into a time, standard time is better... but not as good for states further south where sunset is later.
Winter solstice:
Where Sunrise Sunset
Minneapolis 7:48 AM 4:34 PM
Houston 7:15 AM 5:27 PM
Shifting the time to sunrise at 8:48 and sunset at 5:34 in Minneapolis lacks the impact of shifting sunset to 6:27 PM in Houston.There is no additional hour of "after work, enjoy the still light evening".
The change to permanent daylight savings time has much more support in southern latitudes where the more light after 5pm and tourism has a larger impact on the local economies.
(another article about the "it didn't go as we planned") https://www.nytimes.com/1974/10/01/archives/senate-votes-ret...