That's why 'left' and 'right' have little objective meaning. They're more tribal than explanatory.
> what leftism means to people changes over time with culture
Correct, I don't think there's a good idea what it means in the USA right now, let alone worldwide and across time.
> influences from many leftist writers and philosophers
That's a circular definition though. How do you know they were leftists? By the current or the old meaning? Do old works suddenly become leftist works as the term changes and their author would now qualify as a leftist?
> people's views could boil down to [mistaking a god for a theism] and yet all would easily be considered atheists by themselves and others
There's a difference between a god and a theism so they'd simply be mistaken.
In other words, it's fine if you consider a definition of leftism that includes anarchists, Marxists, collectivists, social democratists and many others to be incorrect, but large groups of people use the term that way and communicate just fine.
The point of the term is a political identifier. If it doesn't encompass anything you believe in but includes your mortal enemies it's not much good.
> large groups of people use the term that way and communicate just fine.
No, they don't. I don't know anyone "on the left" who would happily use it knowing the full scope of what others using it identified as - and validly under your definition. Surely they aren't communicating anything meaningful.
Worse, it encourages those people to label others using their own lax standards, such that everyone who isn't an anarchist, or a marxist, etc, is the polar opposite - "the right". The left is a grab bag, the right is simply everything else.
These terms signify a side a culture war but don't indicate any views or policies which may actually differ between them. They mark "us vs them" without being too specific to swap who is who when needed.
> No, they don't. I don't know anyone "on the left" who would happily use it knowing the full scope of what others using it identified as - and validly under your definition. Surely they aren't communicating anything meaningful.
You're entitled to your own opinion dude, but political ideologies will spend all day arguing between submovements what does and doesn't qualify, and yet it's still possible to get an outline and then make predictions and discourse from there. Leftist or Conservative, you can hear arguing between tankies and anarchists, between "fiscal conservatives" and fundamentalists, mostly at the fringes, because the fringes disagree with the most.
I think what you're trying to say is that the modern left and right are defined by their opposition to eachother ("culture war") and not their value and policy positions. But they do have opposing value and policy opinions, and it's not very hard to write a list. And then you can give names to these opposing groups of values and policy opinions. And you can talk about them and it's not meaningless because there are obvious real-world associations between the values in each group.
"The left of the 1700s French legislature" no longer accurately describes any modern political association so that's probably not a useful lens.
Those people are the legitimate users of the term 'Leftist'. As I was saying, very few normal people would be willing to use a term that lumps them with strident communists who yearn for the good days of the USSR.
It's one thing that some other members of the tribe are commies, but "The Left" was literally coined and adopted by them. (Well, socialists, but no difference.)
The Left fully adopted the post modernist rhetoric of the French philosophers in the 60s and 70s, including actual literal pedophiles trying to remove age of consent laws in order to "queer children before they are stifled by the patriarchy". Again, not something normal people would support if they knew.
The only way this functions is by being so tribal that nobody looks at who else is in the group because they're so busy screaming at everyone outside the group. As proof that it's an identity and not a useful descriptor - your leftist status can be stripped from you and you will be identified as "far right" if you disagree with certain tribal truths.
"The left" is a label people adopt, "the right" is how they label everyone they disagree with. It's a very religious thing, to view all opposition as part of a united collective that wants to destroy you.
> Leftist or Conservative
Conservative what though? That's almost as empty as leftist. As in careful planning, or as in pushing your religion? You have to add 'Fiscal' to conservative before it begins to represent an actual viewpoint instead of a tribal marker.
> it's not meaningless because there are obvious real-world associations between the values in each group.
But vastly less meaning than any actual descriptive. Terms like fiscal conservative, socially liberal, democratic fundamentalist, etc, at least mention the issues a person could believe.
You're free to call yourself whatever you will, but it's undeniable that left/right, conservative, progressive, etc, are so broad that they're identities instead of platforms.
> You're free to call yourself whatever you will, but it's undeniable that left/right, conservative, progressive, etc, are so broad that they're identities instead of platforms
I think we _almost_ agree here, except that they are both identities and platforms.
> "The left" is a label people adopt, "the right" is how they label everyone they disagree with.
Do you feel this is unique to "The left"?
> including actual literal pedophiles trying to remove age of consent laws in order to "queer children before they are stifled by the patriarchy"
You've gone off the rails my dude, and I have no reason to believe you are communicating with a modicum of good faith anymore.
Keep investigating, just remember, they're watching you, just waiting for you to make a small misstep. They want to take away your freedom. They want to turn your children gay. They track your phone location. Stay vigilant. They are always watching.
No, the right is defined by the left, but woke is defined by the people who oppose it, etc. It's one of many. Conservative and liberal are a circle jerk where each is an identity and a slur to threaten dissidents with. (Despite Liberal, at least, having deeper roots than are currently meant by those who use it, it's now meaningless in most places.)
The left is perhaps a bit worse than some identities for being communist, and being used to explaining millions of deaths in terms of progress...
Left/right bothers me even more than liberal/conservative though because it's a reductive lens that people try to push onto everyone around despite it having little to no historical impact on most of them.
> You've gone off the rails my dude, and I have no reason to believe you are communicating with a modicum of good faith anymore.
It's a mere search away but that's just it. I could guarantee that you weren't going to go look because you don't want it to be true. It's a giant umbrella of things nobody is really happy with so nobody looks carefully.
Pedophile leanings of left: https://aeon.co/essays/how-the-french-bohemian-elite-celebra...
Actual government policy impact: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2021/07/26/the-german-exp...
I'm not really talking about actual leftists who embrace their ideology but shrill ideologues with identities and how the term is incorrectly used by many, even for themselves. And it isn't that this specific philosophy is bad, though it seems so, but that it's more officially a leftist platform than a lot of what people would think is.
That most supposed leftists wouldn't support this, if asked away from their peers, is the point.
> I think we _almost_ agree here, except that they are both identities and platforms.
Sure, then I'm just saying that leftist, conservative, etc, are all the way at the 'almost entirely an identity with almost no connection to policy' and 'fiscal conservative' is perhaps roughly in the middle, and some sort of hypothetical amazing group may exist which is vastly more focused on policy than identity.
> Keep investigating, just remember, they're watching you, just waiting for you to make a small misstep. They want to take away your freedom. They want to turn your children gay. They track your phone location. Stay vigilant. They are always watching.
That's pretty funny considering you're the one talking about good faith.
And yes, hello. They do track our phones. Congratulations on conflating a huge issue of national security with your identity politics.
> some sort of hypothetical amazing group may exist which is vastly more focused on policy than identity
I think you should look for it. I honestly can't think of anything that would meet your standard.
> And yes, hello. They do track our phones.
I mean they track you personally. They are always watching. Be careful out there!
Your defensiveness hides some of the only truth in your post. Yes brother, they personally track all of us. Do you think this is good?
Have you thought of asking someone why you answer honesty with scorn and sarcasm?
> the left in {{CURRENTYEAR}} is not defined by these people from the 20th century.
Ho ho. That's like saying communism isn't influenced by Marx because he's dead. If anyone reads any leftist philosophy that's what they're getting. Who do you think the left's thought leaders are then, and how do they repudiate the past wrong-think or do they pretend it's not there?
For instance, if you read some of the earlier American political leaders they were racist and owned slaves, and now their parties repudiate these views and actions. Where are the leftists that disclaim forced collectivism and the rest of the centuries of nonsense, if you want to tell me that the movement changed?
Last I looked though, socialists and communists are still a central part of the movement.
> > more focused on policy than identity
> I think you should look for it. I honestly can't think of anything that would meet your standard.
That's easy - community groups of citizens motivated to fix something. You aren't worrying about a name and national attention and the intellectual legacy of your team, you're just a bunch of parents doing what needs to be done. It gets rarer the further you go from the individuals.