This is not the slam dunk analogy you think it is. Buying stocks
is too darned complicated, which is why even the most astute, sophisticated hedge fund managers cannot beat an index fund on any significant timescale. Because even with all of the publicly-available information, and thorough analysis, you still cannot be sure what is happening internally at any particular company.
Similarly, it is quite literally -- and I do mean this literally -- impossible for anyone to conduct a meaningful and ongoing analysis of their bank.
This leaves basically three options:
* Buy private insurance, which is a fool's errand, as there's no guarantee it would make you whole in the event of a major black swan event.
* Split your account up into an absurd number of institutions. (You get FDIC insurance only per depositor, per account category, per institution. You can't open more accounts of the same category at the same institution).
* Place all your money at one of the Systemically Important Banks, where you basically get unlimited insurance.
Please explain what you thin the rational thing to do here is.