Sneer all you want, but it seems like something lots of people enjoy making and viewing.
...Makes a lot of the advancements moot when they're going to remain buried in a place completely inaccessible to anyone without a hundred million laying around.
2. As good as their tools are, they’re not something that can’t be replicated in something like Blender.
In that shot, he’s interacting with virtual water, sitting on top of a virtual creature and the top of his arm is virtual as well.
The argument online was whether it was fully CG or partially CG. Your version is one that nobody would pick because it wouldn’t work in the context of the shot. The anatomy of the Navi doesn’t map exactly to a human, especially the musculature. You’d also need the geometry in shot as well for interactions with other virtual elements.
It’s very easy to be an armchair expert. It’s much harder once you start delving into the intricacies of the work required.
This is HackerNews not a film critique site after all.