The "premium" stuff is what used to be average quality in the past, while the normal stuff has declined sharply in quality.
now you go to a regular store and find organic heirloom pasture raised no corn or soy fed eggs from a dozen different brands
Not all USDA graded eggs are cage-free, and not all cage-free eggs are graded by USDA. But, eggs packed under a USDA Grade Shield and marketed as cage-free – or with any other production claim – must be source-verified by USDA through onsite farm visits, at least twice annually, to check that the laying hens are housed in the appropriate production system.
https://www.usda.gov/media/blog/2016/09/13/usda-graded-cage-...