The fed has already added hundreds of billions to their books this week and is looking at a 25bps hike. From where we're at, this is effectively QE.
The fed has already added hundreds of billions to their books this week and is looking at a 25bps hike. From where we're at, this is effectively QE.
How are you calculating that?
There was a level at which more modest rates would have gradually bent inflation downward over time, and it would have taken a while (a year or two longer, say). IMO the Fed was too aggressive in trying to stop it asap. They went too far too fast and we'll see a rolling fallout from it for several years yet. Lower rates with elevated inflation for a bit longer, would have been the more prudent choice, than cranking the volume fast and risking a financial crisis.
The “QE” money on the books is a loan as of right now which isn’t QE.
Now will QT continue? Probably not, we’re hitting a liquidity floor. I see rate hikes may continuing though.
During continued QE the Fed will re-purchase these assets when their existing ones mature. During QT on maturity rather than buy assets again they write them off and liquidity (money) is removed from the market.
This may or may not restart inflation but it’s the only option that will be effective.
The Fed has been cargo-culting Volkner in the 80’s without considering this is a different beast. They needed to raise rates but they needed to do it far more deliberately and cautiously. And of course should have started sooner.
We need to accept multiple years of 6-10% (possibly more) inflation or collapse everything and create carnage no one wants to live in.
And all of this with the context that most of the inflation is supply side so interest rate rises are anaemic anyway.
I don’t see a pivot unfortunately even though it seems they are playing with fire here.
I have been arguing for years that they'd never get rates back to where they were pre-GFC as so much debt has been taken on at low rates. Increasing rates to pre-GFC levels will have a massive impact on the ability of borrowers to service debt and push down asset prices.
Now that they're trying to put rates back to pre-GFC levels we can see that playing out. If they choose to continue of this path it will lead to a significant recession.
I’m not trying to doom and gloom though. I’m just saying the Fed did not consider the time aspect of all the bonds/etc and have haphazardly raised rates too fast. If they slow it down it’s not such an issue since bonds respect time. It has been too much too fast. Erratic. Especially since just over a year ago they guided totally differently.
So they need to cut. We need to deal with reasonable inflation for at least 4 more years and then we can aggressively hike rates if need be as the mountain of low interest bonds will be turning the corner.
They need to hold pattern for a few months, then continue raising. The bank crisis is showing no signs of prompting deflation.
When deposits are destroyed, that causes deflation. Deposits aren’t being destroyed. But wealth, in the form of banks’ non-deposit liabilities, is.
The Fed would welcome such deflation (though not its cause). But that doesn’t seem to be likely. That said, nothing which is happening right now is inflationary other than, potentially, the Fed pausing its rate increases.
Not the Fed per se. And that’s the point. Quantity of deposits in the system is preserved. Wealth down. Fed support of banks up. How this balances is uncertain, but nothing is unilaterally inflationary.