I feel like with a lot of these kinds of tools, if I have to actually actively use them, I forget that they exist ('z'[0] ended up being like this for me) and eventually remove them, but something that directly replaces something I use regularly (but hate the UX of) is perfect for me.
Another bit that helps is that I'm not having to learn/remember something new that I'll only have on my laptop. I'll continue to ctrl+R and get a nicer experience, but if I'm ssh'ed into some random box without fzf, ctrl+R will still work, just with a worse experience.