[unmasks them] [audience gasps in terror]
Kodos: It's true, we are aliens. But what are you going to do about it? It's a two-party system; you have to vote for one of us.
[murmurs]
Man1: He's right, this is a two-party system.
Man2: Well, I believe I'll vote for a third-party candidate.
Kang: Go ahead, throw your vote away.
[Kang and Kodos laugh out loud]
[Ross Perot smashes his "Perot 96" hat]
And I say my opponent's 2% tax doesn't go too far enough!
But I just had a hard time evaluating it all.
Boooooooo!
Alright. Abortions for all!
Boooooooo!
Alright. Abortions for some. Miniature American flags for others!
Yaaaaaaaaaaay!
I understand the realities of having a progressive tax system, but Obama crosses a line with me when he is going to tax the rich just to hand it straight over to everyone else in $1000 cash increments. At least in the past the Democrats wanted to buy the poor $1000 in fishing equipment instead of handing out $1000 worth of fish. His plan is the very definition of Marxism.
"During the 2000 campaign, on MSNBC's 'Hardball,' a young woman asked [McCain] why her father, a doctor, should be 'penalized' by being 'in a huge tax bracket.' McCain replied that 'wealthy people can afford more' and that 'the very wealthy, because they can afford tax lawyers and all kinds of loopholes, really don't pay nearly as much as you think they do.' The exchange continued:
YOUNG WOMAN: Are we getting closer and closer to, like, socialism and stuff?...
MCCAIN: Here's what I really believe: That when you reach a certain level of comfort, there's nothing wrong with paying somewhat more"
http://www.newyorker.com/talk/comment/2008/11/03/081103taco_...
The difference between Clinton and Obama is that Clinton didn't hand my hard earned cash directly over to anybody else. Instead he spend money on technical skills training or food stamps for the poor.
from what i can tell, the $500-1k proposed stimulus and tax rebate is, essentially, the exact same thing as the last one. information will be based on 2007 tax reports. you must have previously paid taxes to obtain a check, just like the last round.
i'm not 100% clear on how this check factors into your 2008 taxes, but from the looks of it, it might act as, essentially, a retroactive tax cut from 2007. if you paid your taxes last year, you'll get another check.
but i'm not an expert and would like to see any information showing something contrary to what i've just said.
Also, any increase in taxes is really for very few. In addition to my startup I also own two retail clothing stores that gross over $1.5mm each year. Yet, my share of the net profit is below $250k.
Then there is the health care deduction. I would get that deduction for all of the employees I am already providing health insurance for.
And what about Obama's proposal to eliminate capital gains taxes for small businesses? I haven't seen the details, but the only way for a small business to incur capital gains taxes is by selling assets. I would think a bunch of people working to create companies that they can possibly sell for a large sum would be in favor of eliminating that tax.
His plan is to seize the means of production and establish a dictatorship of the proletariat? Can we get a citation on that?
all tax systems are "spreading the wealth around" unless they're a flat tax system.
obama is proposing a top tax bracket of 39.6%. under the "conservative lord and savior" ronald reagan, the top tax bracket paid 70%. that was eventually lowered to 50%.
sarah palin presides over a state that siphons money from oil companies and uses it to cut checks to their citizens. this year's check was, iirc, for $3200. in addition, alaska is #1 in the country for pork barrel spending, leading the #2 state (arizona, [un?]ironically) by approx. 2500%.
on the y2k campaign, john mccain, when asked about why the questioner's father (a doctor) pays a higher percentage in taxes than others, said this : "Look, here's what I really believe: That when you are, when you reach a certain level of comfort, there's nothing wrong with paying somewhat more."
almost every person in the top 10 richest americans (not all were asked) stated that the current tax system unfairly favors the top. that includes warren buffet and bill gates.
That, and the value of money should not be evaluated solely in terms of its numerical value. 100$ is much more valuable to someone on the edge of poverty than it is to a millionaire. (Ie, Marginal utility.) In that sense, flat taxes are generally considered regressive.
This is stark contrast to what Obama wants to do: take an extra $50000 from a single rich person and giving $1000 in CASH to 50 poor people. Unless the rich person owns stock in malt liquor and plasma television companies, they won't be benefiting at all.
Alaska doesn't "siphon" money off of the oil companies. The oil that the oil companies are extracting is the property of the citizens of Alaska. Alaska is cutting checks to its citizens for what they are properly owed in exchange for their property.
in addition, the point would be to have the money stimulate the poor economy. buying booze and tvs would be the exact point of the checks going out. it would be, theoretically, "bad" if it were to be saved. japan did something similar but set it up so that the people were required to spend their money. like a governmental gift certificate.
also, you don't see anything marxist/communist about a state collectively owning a resource and divvying up profits equally to its citizens?
I'm also very pro second amendment and he has supported some pretty whacked out stuff in that regard. Supporting a bill that would ban all gun stores within 5 miles of a school or park (elminiating 99% of all gun stores in the country) pretty much says enough about that.
Obama wanting more government involvement in health care seems like a genuinely bad idea. Do you want the same type of people at the DMV to dictate what kind of health care you get?
I see nothing marxist about a country or a state owning a resource and divvying up its profits, as long as they didn't take it from someone who already had owned it. Alaska divvying up the profits from oil that sits underneath state owned land is completely different from Alaska taking land away from its owner and divvying up the profits.
i have a group of prominent economists and businessmen that i enjoy/follow/etc., and they unanimously point towards obama's economic policies as what is currently best for the country given the current economic climate.
i am very much willing to sacrifice a personal ideal or two if the country will get itself back on the right track. i tend to take a long view on things. short-term pain for long-term prosperity and goals is what i would prefer. don't want to see the country in a 10+ year malaise like japan after their housing market burst.
just my $0.02, though.
-I have no fear of losing the 2nd amendment rights, after the supreme court ruling this year, and the NRA strength every year, it just isn't going to happen. This is FUD and even Obama himself hasn't said that in MONTHS.
-Does it seem like a bad idea? To me healthcare isn't a cost that is to be minimized, it is a beneifit to be maximized. That is really the difference between the two plans. Obama thinks everyone should have healthcare, McCain thinks we should spend less. Problem is, under McCain total cost of healthcare spending would be less, but per individual it would be higher.
And I really don't understand why anyone is allowed to NOT have insurance in this country. A lot of 20 y/o healthy adults have no insurance to avoid paying the premium. Fine, but when you are 50 they can get coverage? You not only have to spread the risk out among the people, but along their entire life. I'm not allowed to take car insurance out for only the rainy days, why are you allowed to take out health care insurance when you pick and choose, and the familes who plug along year after year with it get stuck with a higher bill each month?
-The state of alaska didn't buy that land from canada, the United States federal government did and gave it to alaska. Yet the state gets to charge a tax that raises the price for fuel for the rest of us. It was the lower 48's money that bought the oil, and it is the lower 48's money that is subsidizing the state today.
Actually, they bought it from Russia (Canada didn't exist at that point). Alaska didn't immediately become a state either, it was administered by the federal gov't for nearly 100 years.
Like with his proposal for 0% Capital Gains tax for Start-ups and Small Businesses? Man he's killin' you AND me with that one.
We've all been funneling money into the pockets of rich people since the Bush tax cuts passed. McCain wants to extend them. For me, Obama is not so much crossing the line as uncrossing it.
Taking a policy like tax policy out of the historical context, you will always be able to label tax increases as socialist and tax decreases as anarchical. These labels mean nothing and pollute the discourse.
The correct question to ask is, what have our previous budget priorities taught us that we can use going forward? Should we, for instance, continue supply-side economics and the dogmas of market deregulation?
All politics about anything is about the redistribution of wealth.
(I didn't vote down your comment, incidentally. I reserve downvotes for forum abuse.)
http://www.investors.com/editorial/editorialcontent.asp?seci...
Obama's sympathies are not just "redistributionist" but genuinely communistic. His racial views are consistently nationalistic. Consistently. But...until he actually wields power (he has voted "present" over 100 times in his short Senate career) it's all speculation.
McCain, by constrast, would be crustily predictable.
This is my only comment on the matter, and I comment because, this voting system makes no sense and it's hard to use it as a feedback device.
People vote you up or down based on whether they want to look at your comment. This site is heavily Obama-ish -- I'm guessing 80% or so. There are some libertarians such as myself rambling around. Probably some Republicans too, but they're deep into some sort of witness protection program I guess. :)
You won't get a conversation. They'll just keep voting your comments into the mud.
Stupid, huh?
[Note: this post is poorly written from here on. Ignore it. I feel like fixing it would be rude to the responder, since it would make his post look nonsensical.]
Not going to vote tomorrow, though. My feeling is that more voters gives the process legitimacy, and I don't want to contribute that.
If you aren't a fan of the political system, why do you affiliate yourself with a political party?
>Not going to vote tomorrow, though. My feeling is that more voters gives the winner legitimacy and a mandate, and since I hate the winner, I don't want to do that.
Anyway, I affiliate myself with the republicans because I agree with a many of their (old school, not Bush-era) positions. I also tend to vote republican in local races since NY/NJ democrats are hopelessly corrupt. However, since I now live in Harlem, even voting in local races is pointless.
Nor do they indicate a lack of McCain support.
That's why I love libertarians -- we're such a pain in the ass to everybody else.
Provide a Tax Cut for Working Families: Obama and Biden will restore fairness to the tax code and provide 150 million workers the tax relief they need. Obama and Biden will create a new "Making Work Pay" tax credit of up to $500 per person, or $1,000 per working family. The "Making Work Pay" tax credit will completely eliminate income taxes for 10 million Americans.
Enact a Windfall Profits Tax to Provide a $1,000 Emergency Energy Rebate to American Families:Barack Obama and Joe Biden will enact a windfall profits tax on excessive oil company profits to give American families an immediate $1,000 emergency energy rebate to help families pay rising bills. This relief would be a down payment on the Obama-Biden long-term plan to provide middle-class families with at least $1,000 per year in permanent tax relief.
Who decides what is "excessive". Fuck that. The margin on my software is several hundred percent, is that excessive? The margin on oil is 4-6%. Does that mean I'm super fucked?
That's interesting, actually. A similar prospect was laughed out of British parliament not too long ago - a parliament far to the left of US tastes.
Why? I want a fair society, and a stable one. I don't want high levels of crime and unreliable health coverage. Nor do I want to feel guilty about enjoying my relative level of privilege. I don't want to be destroyed in the off chance that I'm unable to work due to illness or injury. I definitely don't want to see a violent revolution (much more probable than anyone wants to admit; given 20 more years of the 1980-2009(?) neofeudalism, I'd lay even odds on that one).
Frankly, whether the upper tax bracket is 35 or 39.6 percent is of little interest to me, given the much larger issues at stake. I'll gladly pay a few more percent in taxes, contingent upon positive fortune on my part, in order to live in a better, fairer, and safer society.
Also, here's why redistributive taxation fundamentally makes sense. Poor and middle-class people, in general, spend the bulk of their income on commodities-- food, clothing, consumer goods-- whose prices are set by material supply and demand. Doubling the incomes of the poor is going to enable them to purchase more of these commodities. The growth factor isn't 100%, since there will also be an increase the prices of these commodities (inflation) but it's fairly close-- no worse than 50%, I'd bet. So the poor peoples' standards of living increase if their incomes are doubled. Likewise, a 50% reduction in income will destroy many of them.
On the other hand, wealthy people tend to purchase status goods, such as jewelry, rare (usually shitty, but that's beside the point) art, and trophy real estate. If the wealthy are suddenly made twice as rich, the prices of all the Manhattan apartments and paint-factory-vomit "modern art" works would instantly double. The same would be true if their income were halved. As long as these individuals' relative rankings were unchanged, their standards of living would change only slightly. One exception might be for those who wish to purchase a rivate jet, since a major expenditure in that pursuit is oil, a commodity. So private jets might become less affordable. Boo-hoo. The truth is that you could increase the tax rates on the very rich ($2.5 million+ per year) to 80 percent and, although they would feel intense pain due to the numerical changes and perceived loss of status, their lifestyles wouldn't change substantially, due to price reductions for most of the things they care about.
It makes a lot more sense for anyone who owns a business to pay an extra 3% tax on a better economy, than save a little on taxes in exchange for a terrible economy. It seems like cutting your nose to spite your face.
The average guy making $300,000 a year and with a million dollars in the stock market saved $80,000 in taxes over the last 8 years, and lost $400,000 in the stock market in the last 2 months. Not a great trade.
"Selfish" is a loaded, emotional, subjective term. Not something to base a policy on (and I don't think Obama or McCain is doing that)
Capitalism is based almost ENTIRELY on acting selfishly. However, as we can clearly see, people suffer greatly from the near literal implementation of capitalism. Therefore, there needs to be a system in place to help those people who have become victims of it.
...hitler, etc. therefore such as.
The "yacht tax" a few years ago provides a useful lesson. The federal govt in its infinite wisdom added an significant tax to pleasure boats. Surprise - folks who could afford to buy outside the US did so. Folks who couldn't cut back. Folks building boats in the US lost their jobs.
If yacht makers sell a $20 million yacht, it doesn't mean half that money goes to the workers and the other half goes to the CEO.
No. It's called profit maximization.
They pay the workers barely enough to live on while the board gets 30 times that amount. Maximize profits.
The Yacht tax didn't work because yacht owners found loopholes in the tax code such as declaring their yacht as a second home, etc.
Yacht owners buy high-quality, high-value yachts. It doesn't matter if they were made in Missouri or Malaysia, as long as they're expensive and are made of some rare resource.
Stop spreading your bullshit half-baked "ideas" about capitalism. Read the damn business section of a newspaper sometime.
And nearly all boat yards are sole proprietor private enterprises, so their is no board to pay out to.
And there is no loophole in the tax code. Go to another country, buy a boat flagged their. Keep it outside US waters. Fly to it when you want to go on vacation. People rarely cruise in the US anyway, it is Bahamas, the Med, etc. The loop hole you are referring to if anything is flagging yourself as commercial vs private, and it has to do with income tax on charters - not the initial purchase.
The yacht tax was collected from US manufacturer and importerss, not the buyers, so it didn't matter what the buyers claimed.
The boat-building industry in the US took a huge hit. It turns out that rich folks can keep their boats overseas and poorer folks can do without. That didn't happen before the tax.
Maybe you don't think much of building boats but feel free to explain how losing their jobs did the US workers was good for them. They sure didn't like it.
> They pay the workers barely enough to live on while the board gets 30 times that amount. Maximize profits.
If you really believe that the workers are getting screwed, it's easy enough to set up a company that doesn't screw workers. If you're right, you'll get better workers, they'll make more money, and the money that you save by not paying "the board" can be used to undercut the "evil companies", driving them out of biz.
It doesn't take much money to prove that you're correct, but it does take the courage to risk your money. I'm sure that you're doing that right now, right?
BTW - feel free to name three companies whose profit is 30x the employee expense. (I'm making it easy - the profit can go to stockholders not on the board.) Include cites where we can verify.
> That logic is completely asinine and you know it.
It's asinine that folks will try to avoid taxes? Wowsers. It's asinine that folks will do less of things that are taxed? Better tell Congress that the taxes to discourage (their intended goal) and benefits to encourage (again, their intent) don't work.
> Read the damn business section of a newspaper sometime.
I do. That's where I read about the boat companies laying off workers. That's where I read about tax effects.
The boat workers preferred building boats to being unemployed; we know that because they could have "unemployed" themselves before they were laid-off.
Are they wrong?
Democrats are only generous with other people's money.
1. Charity is not a pissing contest and you know that.
2. The McCain's sit on a $100 million company. They have some money to throw around. Ask his wife to release her tax returns from the last few years, and then we can talk about "charity".
3. The amount of money given to a charity does not translate into number of problems fixed or alleviated and you know that.
4. A selfish pussy is a cheapskate that would rather watch a person starve than spend one penny on food to feed him. While extreme, this is essentially a selfish pussy.
Since McCain spent far more feeding (and housing) other people than Obama and Biden combined....
Then again, that's true of conservatives vs liberals in the US - US conservatives give a larger percentage of their income to charity.
> The amount of money given to a charity does not translate into number of problems fixed or alleviated and you know that.
Is the same true of money taken by govt?
Voting to take most of someone else's money for myself and/or those whose beliefs I approve of, and to call agents of the government to arrest those who resist --> "caring, altrusitic, benevolent".
If McCain had a plan to realisticly bring federal taxes down to 15% without a big deficit, I'd be all for it. But the reality is the Bush tax cuts are tax cuts without spending cuts.
Obama takes money from the rich and refunds it to the poor. Some call this buying their votes. Bush took out loans and gave the cash to the rich. Isn't that basically the same thing?