And thank you for saying this:
Downvoting says that “this is not a contribution to productive discussion on HN”.
If it is worth discussing, it is not worth downvoting.
I happen to think so as well. I don't downvote things unless they are completely derailing the conversation, disingenuous, malicious, etc. Any good-faith argument, especially if expressed clearly and with details, should be upvoted, even if you disagree with it!
I usually agree with pg BUT I disagree with him that downvotes should be used to express disagreement. They should be used to express bad faith, bad form, etc.