On the other hand, as someone not listening to a lot of classical music, it's an interesting problem for sure, but as I mostly drag the mp3 folder onto foobar2000... I don't think I get the "problem" part of the problem, maybe I would if I used the likes of spotify more :P
Cluttering up an app most people use to search for Ed Sheeran or w/e with data attributes like 'conductor', 'orchestra', 'composer', etc. — all of which are meaningless to 'most people' — makes the app less usable for most people (including myself, when I'm not listening to classical). The 0.5% of people who actually want these features can just download this app.
Calling it now this app will be quietly discontinued by 2025. Doesn’t justify the engineering overhead for a different meta data grouping/filtering. None of this sounds anywhere near as complicated as people are making it out to be.
I've been growing and maintaining a collection of classical music for ten years now, which means I've been trying for ten years to solve this problem with tools designed for the same use case as Apple Music. If it were as easy as you claim, then by now I would have solved it at least well enough that taking a physical CD off a physical rack and putting it in a physical player never felt like the more convenient option.
If the app's discontinued in a couple of years, it won't be because it never made sense to build, especially given that I'm sure they're reusing most of both the frontend and backend for Apple Music as it exists today. It'll be because they're addressing one of the world's pickiest audiences, and not succeeding in getting enough right enough of the time - on that score I wish them the best of luck; on every other, I don't think I need to, not least because they might well succeed in selling me an Apple Music subscription with this.
I am just struggling to find a need to have a separate app, I guess UI/UX perhaps but I still echo the same fear as the parent commenter. I am sure Apple has the money to support it, and while I love classical music, I am not downloading another app just to consume it.
As I said before, I've spent a decade trying to solve this problem with the same kinds of approaches you're advocating here - that is, using tooling built for general music. That I haven't succeeded doesn't necessarily mean much, but how likely do you think it is that Apple's product and engineering teams didn't try the same before deciding they needed to ship a whole new app about it?
If that's true, why does every mainstream music app do such a terrible job with classical musical?
Possible because they think something like "none of this sounds anywhere near as complicated as people are making it out to be."
One of the AppStore image shows the 'Wiki' part of the player: https://is4-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/PurpleSource126/v4/...
----The AppStore Description-----
Get the app designed specifically for classical music. Available to Apple Music subscribers at no additional cost. Instantly find any recording in the world’s largest classical music catalog with search built for the genre. Enjoy the highest audio quality available (up to 192 kHz/24-bit Hi-Res Lossless) and hear classical favorites like never before in spatial audio, all with zero ads.
Apple Music Classical also makes it easy for beginners to get acquainted with the genre thanks to hundreds of Essentials playlists, insightful composer biographies, deep-dive guides for many key works, and intuitive browsing features.
The Ultimate Classical Experience
• Get unlimited access to the world’s largest classical music catalog (over 5 million tracks) with everything from new releases to celebrated masterpieces, plus thousands of exclusive albums.
• Search by composer, work, conductor, or even catalog number, and find specific recordings instantly.
• Listen in the highest audio quality (up to 192 kHz/24 bit Hi-Res Lossless) and enjoy thousands of recordings in immersive spatial audio with Dolby Atmos.
• Benefit from complete and accurate metadata to make sure you know exactly what and who you are playing.
• Learn while you listen, with thousands of composer biographies, descriptions of key works, and more.
• Listen using AirPlay on compatible wireless devices.