I used to live in towns like this that enforced these limits with rabid Sherif deputies and it is VERY nice. The noise levels are much lower and being around cars doing 20MPH is so much nicer than ones doing 35 in a 25. Especially with separated paths.
Reducing speed limits from 25 MPH to 20 MPH reduces fatal collisions by about 25%. It's a kind of a no brainer. Additionally, reducing speed limits to 20 MPH means that cars are not able to legally pass Class A electric bicycles traveling on the same roads that are limited to 20 MPH.
I'm not necessarily against a 20 MPH speed limit (or even lower) in many neighborhoods, but what exactly makes it a no brainer?
The variable you're mentioning is deaths. Are there other variables and unintended consequences to consider? If the only criteria used to evaluate speed limits is a reduction in deaths, then a 15 or 10 or 5 MPH speed limit would be superior and a no brainer by your perspective.
(I don't think we'd necessarily disagree about all that much, but just questioning the process of how you're getting there.)
Private cars take up too much space and are way too dangerous in pedestrianized areas. Especially since most cars, are made with limited visibility due to roll over standards. It blew my mind when I bought a 2013 Honda and I could barely see anything compared to my 90' Civic. I'm constantly ducking around A Pillars in parking lots to see to my left.
20 mph is plenty reasonable on city streets.
Parked cars are extremely safe. The IIHS should look into it.