I didn’t have this reflexive reaction, but I can understand why one might if familiar with the way regional references can be coded language. That said,
> It does a disservice to an achievement, if in fact there is one. A part of me is now sort of doubtful that this isn't a "cause celebre" sort of situation.
I don’t think it does a disservice. The author isn’t noting the achievement because of the students’ identity, only noting that the objective achievement being achieved by students with systemic disadvantages might be inspiring to others facing similar disadvantages. As an educator, one of their responsibilities is to help students overcome arbitrary barriers to their education and enjoy the benefits of the same education as their peers. It’s one of zillions of implied responsibilities educators have beyond the material itself. But you can’t fault any educator for recognizing when one factor of that might be even a little less fraught by centuries of reinforced barriers to their students.
The rest of the paragraph you quoted seems to reflect your own view:
> which should inspire anyone — no matter what their ethnic, gender or socio-demographic background — that excellence in your chosen field of study is always attainable if you have enough joy and passion for what you do.
The difference is that the author seems to recognize that wishing doesn’t make it so, that systemic and historical barriers don’t vanish if you don’t mention them.
The rest of the post is focused on the objective details. I hope that won’t be lost because you or anyone is sensitive to acknowledgment that humans don’t exist in a vacuum even if you that for the math they’re reasoning about.
Also cultural. Don't underestimate how big a headwind an anti-education subculture can be to the people in it!
I mean, honestly… it just is. Is it a new proof? I believe that it is. Is it any good? Yeah, sure, it's pretty clever. Is it really an all-over-the-news special kind of achievement? No. It simply wouldn't be all over the news if not for… uh, non-mathematical reasons.
Allegedly it's special, because it's trigonometric, and trigonometric proofs of it are indeed special. But this one is… let's say it's "trigonometric with an asterisk". Both because of the series, and because it is kinda analogous to a known geometric proof. And the first one truly trigonometric proof, which was really special, wasn't as much celebrated, as this one (but, of course, the internet was a bit quieter place back then).
And, yes, I agree that it does a disservice to an achievement. And I'm completely positive that it is an achievement no matter what — every new proof is, and it's especially true when the theorem is well-known (and there are very few more famous than this one). So, honestly, I'd like if we wouldn't have this discussion at all, and could just stick to the matter. But the problem is we probably wouldn't even hear of it, if not for those "non-mathematical" reasons. Because by itself it isn't that huge. I would love if every new proof of a famous theorem would be highlighted and celebrated on the Internet as much, as this one, but it simply isn't the case.
It's understandable, so it's neither good nor bad IMO, but I'm just saying that your suspicion is definitely correct.
The reason the framing rubs me the wrong way is because it feeds a narrative that people from New Orleans (regardless of race) are somehow novel for doing something fancy. I was born in New Orleans so I have some slight offense at the implication that the geography is somehow notable. It’s like “oh wow, even people from some Southern flyover city can do some smart stuff too.”
However what is interesting about this story is the girls go to St Mary’s which is a catholic school created for black people during the segregation era founded by an the second oldest order of American black nuns just after the Civil War. The history of the school is fascinating.
Imagine if more kids had the opportunity to go to high quality private schools but can’t due to financial constraints (St Mary’s costs about $9k per year which is a lot of money for those in Louisiana.)
These girls can write their own ticket now — I hope they end up staying in math and do something extraordinary with their lives.
I’ve had similar thoughts in the past but figured out I personally do better when I channel the doubt into excitement for anyone’s’ potential claim.
I’m happy that a human—or humans, in this case—believe(s) they have discovered a novel way to do something and want to share it with the world.
That doesn’t mean I take the claim at face value, I don’t, and want to wait for secondary confirmation. But it’s true that I no longer worry if I’m hearing about something because of an agenda…because I know I am, in all cases.
So I skip that part and just stick with the hopeful awe.