Amazing that no one else was willing to sponsor an event featuring the first woman president of the ACLU.
Amazing that no one else was willing to sponsor an event featuring the first woman president of the ACLU.
wrt free speech I find poppers paradox of intolerance relevant. a unhealthy overdose of Der Stürmer and lashing out against some scapegoat minorities lead Europe into WWII
in simple words: you _have_ to put limits on bullshitting else your freedom is shat on.
Not really. He’s making these pronouncements and reforms. He isn’t deferring to each bishop in their own territory.
wrt free speech I find
Regardless of what you or I think about this issue there was an organization that stood for one position on it for almost a century.
However good the arguments are, I don’t expect the National Pro-Life Religious Council to decide that maybe abortions aren’t so bad after all.
so in a way he's is managing "free speech"
which is our topic here: how do we establish the rules for speech which support unity and support for our neighbors and which end oppression of weak minorities? which speech rules foster growth and fairness and justice and health for all?
Except that:
1. Hitler rose to power mostly on the back of widespread civil unrest caused by the conditions placed on Germany for being the loser of WW1. Jews weren't popular anywhere in Europe at that time, anti-semitism was not a uniquely German thing, but Hitler came to power there because the German people could see no way out of the crushing poverty and despair caused by the reparations they were being forced to pay.
2. Germany didn't have strong free speech or political protections in the runup to Hitler taking power which is why a political party was able to have its own shock troops on the street beating up other parties. The first thing Hitler did was get rid of free speech and the free competition of ideas more generally, because the sort of people who hate free speech are exactly those people who are engaged in bullshitting and don't want other people to point it out.
If Germany had strong democratic and free speech institutions, and the victors in WW1 had paid more attention to rebuilding Germany in their own image instead of treating it as a loot box, then Hitler would likely never have happened. He'd have been beaten back at the ballot box and become a failed politician of no real note.
Amazing how the world has forgotten that part of it, and how in vogue totalitarianism was in the 1930s
there problem pre 1933 was that Hitler could spread whichever slander he wanted, "free speech", just louder and bullshittier than anybody else. "free bullshitting" because "free speech"
and the problem post 1933 was that nobody else was allowed to speak freely any more.
and PS: he already started losing at the ballot box. he just FUD-ed the moderate conservatives enough to have ether back.
1. The overly-broad application of the First Amendment to conservative SCOTUS decisions giving corporations 1A rights.
2. The financial success of propaganda corporations such as Fox News, and their poisoning of public discourse.
3. The weakening of democratic institutions and the ability for people to govern themselves as they choose
Given that, is it any surprise that people are lashing out? MTG gets softball 60 Minutes segments. Perhaps people are coming to understand that this isn’t a viable way forward.
1) arguing that private companies arbitrarily deciding what they want to allow on their platform, even under direct request from government departments and powerful individuals, is actually good and needed to protect minorities.
2) They also defend one set of "propaganda corporations" from the other set of "propaganda corporations"; they don't rail against extremely partisan coverage, they have come to consider it a patriotic duty to even suppress true information that would give the opposition ammo.
3) They support the FBI and the CIA over Congress and the democratic process. Democratic processes are ridiculed as "popularity contests." They support US military interventions and sanctions regimes abroad against democratically elected leaders.
Fox started the problem with our news, but now we have similiar outlets on both left and right doing it. Don't watch them.