It’s people repeating this idea that math has suddenly changed within the last 20 years or something that is ridiculous.
It’s people repeating this idea that math has suddenly changed within the last 20 years or something that is ridiculous.
There is no math that claims the price of a stock should be some form of discounted future cashflows since at least the 90s.
Since then, all models have been multifactor ones, with fundamentals (quality, value) being only one fragment of the market, sector and country residualized stock returns.
What `epups` is explaining to you is the basis of behavioral economics, which is the de facto current leading theory since its foundations were Nobel prized 20 years ago...
Would you spend one US dollar to make a million a year? Of course, but what such investments would ever exist?
And so instruments which bare gains over time have some value, which is calculated by the means of cost of investment to returns over time.
If there are a market of such instruments, they can and will be in competition with each other.
This "things are only what people value them at" stuff is for the birds. Those other people you're talking about are actually calculating their investments. Others with such mentality will follow, not knowing what they're doing, and taking missteps when the goods are already gone.
What you think is "accepted by everyone else" is what you're seeing at face value. There are reasons behind actions. Those actions in and of themself have no meaning without context.
The mathematics of investment have never, ever changed in any meaningful way. The history of debts, interest rates, and returns have always fluctuated, but the math hasn't.
Anyone suggesting otherwise is uninformed.
The field of finance studies how to value various assets, beginning with fixed cash flows over time, and then introducing things like risk.