>Wait, I cut carbs out almost completely, why are my numbers getting worse?
Because you're eating more fat, and probably more saturated fat in particular, which means more intramyocellular lipids, and hence, you're becoming more insulin resistant. Cutting the carbohydrate consumption only masks the IR, at best. The simplest explanation is that "phsiological IR" is just plain-old insulin resistance: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6602127/
> OGTT is useless
It's probably the best cheap test for clinically diagnosing insulin resistance: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23327814/
Fasting BG, fasting insulin, and HbA1C only measure blood sugar control, which severe carbohydrate restriction can sometimes obtain, but without actually reversing the underlying pathology of IR. An OGTT, by contrast, measures your insulin response to a bolus of glucose in real time.
Fat also has the lowest thermic effect, a paltry 2-3%. Besides having the most calories per gram (9 vs 4 for protein or carb), it provides by far the cheapest, easiest calories for your body to digest.
>provides by far the cheapest, easiest calories for your body to digest
I mean metabolically cheap and easy. Your body expends the least energy digesting fat (2-3%, or 2-3 calories worth of energy for every 100 fat calories you consume), and the most digesting protein (>20%). Add to that the fact that fat has more than twice the calories per gram that carbohydrate and protein do, and it's little wonder why so many people fail with keto.
The assumption here is that this is a temporary/reversible condition. At least it was in my case.
For the record, I did a low carb diet for 6 months. I was in ketosis for much of it, with temporary periods of break when it was unavoidable (during travel, lack of food options, social setting). I feel exogenous ketones helped me with the process of getting back in ketosis.