Should we have access (by law) to the code that makes recommendations on content? That seems like a governmental overreach. If that was the case, then we should have to have direct access to the brain of every editor/layout person of every newspaper. Why was one story above the fold vs below the fold vs on page 4? I don't see a whole lot of distinction between those two.
Once we get access to that, how do we keep people from abusing these algorithms on the supply side? Thought SEO sites were bad before? Guess what happens when those sites know what they're _actually targeting_, as opposed to blindly guessing!
As a question, how well do you understand the recommender system that you've created? For a given piece of content, would you be able to guess at the penetration into the platform? As an outsider, I sometimes feel like the recommender systems I interact with have grown out of the platform holder's control (see: Nazi/ISIS/ISIL propaganda on YouTube, etc.). I think these are the points the article is reacting to.
So if the article is saying "I would really rather not see Nazi/ISIS/ISIL propaganda," then, ok, that's good. That's a good want. But we're going to need an algorithm to determine what that propaganda _is_, and then downrank that for that user.
So, is the conclusion of the article... misguided? Sure! Is the desire of the author valid?
I don't know. I don't have time to read these articles.